The captain of Chelsea Football Club and the English national side, John Terry, was found not guilty and cleared of racially abusing Queens Park Rangers footballer Anton Ferdinand at Westminster Magistrates Court on 31 July 2012.
Ferdinand alleged that Terry aimed abusive language at him, describing him as "black" and using extreme sexual swearwords. Terry has not denied using the word “black” or using extreme insulting language of a sexual nature. Rather, he defended himself in court by insisting that during the game between the two West London clubs on 23 October 2011 he was merely repeating a phrase he believed Ferdinand had accused him of using during an exchange of on-field expletive insults.
Chief Magistrate Howard Riddle, in his written judgment, said it was “highly unlikely” that during the match Ferdinand had accused Terry of racially abusing him but that it was possible that Terry believed that Ferdinand had made an accusation and that “it is therefore possible that what he [Mr Terry] said was not intended as an insult, but rather as a challenge to what he believed had been said to him”. Riddle went on to state that upon reviewing all the evidence before him, he could not find Terry guilty because there remained an element of doubt that Terry intended to racially insult the Queens Park Rangers player.
Regardless of whether one agrees with the court’s reasoning for delivering a not guilty verdict, the position is this: John Terry has been acquitted and cleared by the courts of racially abusing Anton Ferdinand. Why, therefore, is the Chelsea footballer still under investigation by the Football Association, the league’s governing body?
In much the same way as an employer is able to conduct its own internal investigation at the same time as a police investigation involving one of its employees is ongoing, the FA is free and able to conduct its own investigation regardless of whether or not the case has been through the English court system. The FA has its own set of rules and if, as a result of an investigation, the FA finds that John Terry has contravened one or more of their rules then he can be disciplined by the FA. In effect, the ruling by the courts was only ‘half-time’. Only once the FA investigation is concluded can the final whistle sound. An FA spokesman commented on the day of the court judgment; "the FA notes the decision in the John Terry case and will now seek to conclude its own enquiries”. Indeed, the FA has been reviewing the evidence and an FA commission, which will meet on Tuesday, will decide if Terry is guilty of racially insulting Ferdinand and in the process if he has failed to comply with FA rules. The Commission, chaired by an independent QC, will reach a verdict on the charge against Terry of using “abusive and/ or insulting words and/ or behaviour” towards Ferdinand including “a reference to ethnic origin and/ or race”. Terry denies the charge.
The FA Commission will operate with a lower burden of proof than the courts and is able to find Terry guilty of the alleged offence on the balance of probabilities. The court could only find Terry guilty if it judged that it was beyond reasonable doubt that he had used racially insulting language. Chief Magistrate Howard Riddle said in his written judgment that “in [these] circumstances, there being a doubt, the only verdict the court can record is one of not guilty." The FA commission does not have to be certain that Terry uttered the words in question as a racial insult.
The court’s ‘not guilty’ verdict will, however, still have a bearing on the outcome of the FA investigation. The Daily Mail revealed on 18 September that Terry’s legal team aim to have the FA investigation dismissed on the basis that FA Rule 6.8 which states that the results of relevant civil or criminal proceedings are 'presumed to be correct and the facts presumed to be true' by FA regulatory commissions.
The FA has already taken action in 2012 in relation to complaints made a Manchester United footballer earlier this year. Patrice Evra who plays for the Manchester club alleged that Luis Suarez, who plays for rivals Liverpool, racially abused him during a game between the sides last season. This case did not go through the courts, but an FA investigation concluded that Suarez was guilty and dismissed Suarez’s defence that cultural misunderstanding prompted his use of the word “negro”. Indeed the Commission ruled it didn’t need to prove Suarez intended his use of the word “negro” to be insulting; rather it had to decide whether the use of the word “negro” was insulting. The Commission ruled that Suarez was guilty and he was subsequently fined and banned for eight matches.
On this basis, if the Commission rules that Terry’s use of the word “black” and accompanying insults of a sexual nature is offensive then Terry’s defence that he was merely repeating the phrase he believed Ferdinand had accused him of using should, in all likelihood, fail.
23/09/2012
21/02/2012
Haye vs Chisora
On Saturday night the press conference which followed the heavyweight fight between world champion Vitali Klitschko, of the Ukraine, and the British challenger, Dereck Chisora of Peckham, was interrupted when David Haye, a former opponent of Vitali’s younger brother, Wladimir, appeared at the back of the room and launched a tirade of verbal abuse aimed at Klitschko and his manager. Haye believes he agreed a deal for a fight with Klitschko in December last year and seemed bemused when Klitschko’s manager intimated that his charge would overlook Haye and any other British fighter when choosing the opponent for his next title bout.
Chisora became rather miffed that Haye had taken centre stage at a press conference held to discuss and debate the twelve rounds he had completed just hours earlier. And, instead of ignoring Haye’s palpable presence, Chisora told Haye he was an “embarrassment”; that his brooding and theatrical performance in the aftermath of his points defeat to Wladimir Klitschko in which he blamed his defeat on a broken toe had “messed it up for young British fighters coming through”. Haye responded to Chisora’s rhetoric of “how’s your toe” by informing Chisora that he was a “loser”. Agitated, Chisora vacated his seat and marched towards Haye to confront him, removing his jacket on the way. Commence the fracas. Punches were thrown by both boxers and accusations have been made by the Chisora camp that David Haye used a bottle in an attempt to inflict injury on the Boxer from Peckham.
The actions of Haye and Chisora have landed both in trouble with the German police and the British Board of Boxing. German prosecutors have informed the media that both boxers could face jail terms for their violent behaviour. Journalists and prominent figures in British boxing have called for Chisora to face a lengthy ban and some have questioned whether he should be allowed to fight again.
Neither boxer has denied that he did nothing wrong in the melee that ensued. Both clearly regret the incident if not solely because it could put an end to their careers in boxing.
However, David Haye’s trainer and closest ally, Adam Booth, today argued that David Haye acted in self defence. Booth insists “"What David did was a defensive reflex. The man said he was going to slap him, walked 20 yards towards him, took his jacket off, went straight into a head butt and shoved his fist into David's chin. Everything was a defensive reflex from David”. And, he is not alone. In an interview with the BBC, the president of the Federation of German Professional Boxers, Dr Thomas Putz, said he "saw Chisora run directly to David Haye ... and attack him…David Haye only did the right thing to Chisora. He saved himself. It was self-defence”.
Was David Haye acting in self-defence? Or do his actions constitute an act of violence; of bodily harm.
The defence of self defence in English law arises from both Statute: the Criminal Law Act 1967 and from common law. Without using too much legal jargon, an individual is entitled to use reasonable force to protect himself if he genuinely believes that he is in danger or is the victim of an unlawful act, such as an assault.
The principle was established in the case of Beckford: “A defendant is entitled to use reasonable force to protect himself, others for whom he is responsible and his property. It must be reasonable”. What does ‘reasonable’ mean? Well, in a criminal case, that question can only be answered by a jury who judge the facts of the case, but in essence, the defendant, in this scenario David Haye, can be forgiven for making decisions that are not entirely rational and therefore, the test must balance the objective standard of a reasonable person by attributing some of the subjective knowledge of the defendant, including what he believed about the circumstances, even if mistaken. An individual may even take a pre-emptive strike if he honestly believes the circumstances demand it. This means that a person can use force if he believes that there is a threat of imminent violence if they do not act first. However, even allowing for mistakes made in a crisis, the amount of force must be proportionate and reasonable given the value of the interests being protected and the harm likely to be caused by use of force.
Applying the law to the Haye versus Chisora it is clear that it was Chisora who approached Haye having threatened to “slap” him and as he did so he removed his jacket and told a security guard not to intervene. He stood at Haye’s feet and leaned his head into Haye’s face. It was at this point that Haye used physical force against Chisora and hit him. Was this violent act by Haye one of self defence? Possibly so.
Haye could argue that he feared an imminent attack by Chisora; therefore that it was reasonable in the circumstances, fearing an assault by Chisora, to use an act of force against Chisora in order to protect himself. Arguing that the amount of force he used was reasonable and proportionate could prove more difficult for Haye, especially as he appears to have used a bottle when striking Chisora. But, Haye could argue that he was holding a bottle at the moment he feared an imminent assault by Chisora and therefore was not able to rid himself of the bottle when he acted in self defence. In any event, in order for a defence of self defence to be successful, were this to end in a criminal court, the jury would have to accept that it was reasonable for Haye to act in the way he did; that his actions were not excessive.
Haye is now in the United States on holiday. German police still want to speak to Haye and one must suspect his journey back to the UK will be via Germany.
Chisora became rather miffed that Haye had taken centre stage at a press conference held to discuss and debate the twelve rounds he had completed just hours earlier. And, instead of ignoring Haye’s palpable presence, Chisora told Haye he was an “embarrassment”; that his brooding and theatrical performance in the aftermath of his points defeat to Wladimir Klitschko in which he blamed his defeat on a broken toe had “messed it up for young British fighters coming through”. Haye responded to Chisora’s rhetoric of “how’s your toe” by informing Chisora that he was a “loser”. Agitated, Chisora vacated his seat and marched towards Haye to confront him, removing his jacket on the way. Commence the fracas. Punches were thrown by both boxers and accusations have been made by the Chisora camp that David Haye used a bottle in an attempt to inflict injury on the Boxer from Peckham.
The actions of Haye and Chisora have landed both in trouble with the German police and the British Board of Boxing. German prosecutors have informed the media that both boxers could face jail terms for their violent behaviour. Journalists and prominent figures in British boxing have called for Chisora to face a lengthy ban and some have questioned whether he should be allowed to fight again.
Neither boxer has denied that he did nothing wrong in the melee that ensued. Both clearly regret the incident if not solely because it could put an end to their careers in boxing.
However, David Haye’s trainer and closest ally, Adam Booth, today argued that David Haye acted in self defence. Booth insists “"What David did was a defensive reflex. The man said he was going to slap him, walked 20 yards towards him, took his jacket off, went straight into a head butt and shoved his fist into David's chin. Everything was a defensive reflex from David”. And, he is not alone. In an interview with the BBC, the president of the Federation of German Professional Boxers, Dr Thomas Putz, said he "saw Chisora run directly to David Haye ... and attack him…David Haye only did the right thing to Chisora. He saved himself. It was self-defence”.
Was David Haye acting in self-defence? Or do his actions constitute an act of violence; of bodily harm.
The defence of self defence in English law arises from both Statute: the Criminal Law Act 1967 and from common law. Without using too much legal jargon, an individual is entitled to use reasonable force to protect himself if he genuinely believes that he is in danger or is the victim of an unlawful act, such as an assault.
The principle was established in the case of Beckford: “A defendant is entitled to use reasonable force to protect himself, others for whom he is responsible and his property. It must be reasonable”. What does ‘reasonable’ mean? Well, in a criminal case, that question can only be answered by a jury who judge the facts of the case, but in essence, the defendant, in this scenario David Haye, can be forgiven for making decisions that are not entirely rational and therefore, the test must balance the objective standard of a reasonable person by attributing some of the subjective knowledge of the defendant, including what he believed about the circumstances, even if mistaken. An individual may even take a pre-emptive strike if he honestly believes the circumstances demand it. This means that a person can use force if he believes that there is a threat of imminent violence if they do not act first. However, even allowing for mistakes made in a crisis, the amount of force must be proportionate and reasonable given the value of the interests being protected and the harm likely to be caused by use of force.
Applying the law to the Haye versus Chisora it is clear that it was Chisora who approached Haye having threatened to “slap” him and as he did so he removed his jacket and told a security guard not to intervene. He stood at Haye’s feet and leaned his head into Haye’s face. It was at this point that Haye used physical force against Chisora and hit him. Was this violent act by Haye one of self defence? Possibly so.
Haye could argue that he feared an imminent attack by Chisora; therefore that it was reasonable in the circumstances, fearing an assault by Chisora, to use an act of force against Chisora in order to protect himself. Arguing that the amount of force he used was reasonable and proportionate could prove more difficult for Haye, especially as he appears to have used a bottle when striking Chisora. But, Haye could argue that he was holding a bottle at the moment he feared an imminent assault by Chisora and therefore was not able to rid himself of the bottle when he acted in self defence. In any event, in order for a defence of self defence to be successful, were this to end in a criminal court, the jury would have to accept that it was reasonable for Haye to act in the way he did; that his actions were not excessive.
Haye is now in the United States on holiday. German police still want to speak to Haye and one must suspect his journey back to the UK will be via Germany.
09/04/2009
One More Dance
One more dance,
One more dance with you,
Follow your steps,
Learn from you,
yearn for you,
love you,
miss you,
you liked dancing,
you liked to lead,
I followed,
I need you,
I feel you,
I can’t feel you,
Lost you.
One more dance with you,
Follow your steps,
Learn from you,
yearn for you,
love you,
miss you,
you liked dancing,
you liked to lead,
I followed,
I need you,
I feel you,
I can’t feel you,
Lost you.
16/09/2008
Olympic Success?
It was heralded as the one of the greatest Olympic Games in history. Beijing 2008 began with a remarkable opening ceremony; its highlight the sight of thousands of men beating drums inside the gigantic newly built Olympic Stadium, romantically named the Bird's Nest owing to its thatched design.
But, was it worth it? Did the Olympics justify its billion-Dollar price tag? Should China have been the host nation in the first instance? Broken promises, infringement of human rights, and lack of freedom for its people (and the journalists covering the Games) are reasons that suggest not. And of course we all know about the tragic events that have taken place in Tibet. But what is even more depressing is the vast amount of money spent on the Olympic games that could have been spent on more worthwhile causes. Yes, to stage an event as magnificent as an Olympic games requires large sums of cash, but this games broke all spending records. People were thrown from their homes, which were demolished to make way for new huge and expensive sports arenas that now lie dormant and empty and new apartment buildings were constructed for tourists that came and went, and that ordinary Chinese cannot afford.
The Olympics is traditionally a competition that has encouraged all nations to compete and come together in a friendly atmosphere. Taking part came first, winning was only a bonus. Unfortunately, more markedly in Beijing than in previous competitions winning gold medals took precedent over the art of pure competion.
Historically China has been a bastion of equality under the communist banner. In 1978 however this all changed when Deng Shaio Ping originated the Open Door Policy to foster a commercial mentality, exclaiming that 'to get rich is to get glorious'. This mentality has seeped into all areas of Chinese life, and particularly into the sports arena. China invested millions of dollars in training schemes, sports centres and coaches not to cement a sporting legacy but simply win the most gold medals, and top the medals table in 2008. This mentality even extended itself in the gymnastics arena in the form of entering fourteen year old girls with fake passports into competitions to win Golds in front of audiences around the world. Sadly, Liu Xiang was scorned and berated when he was forced to pull out of the 110 meter hurdle competition with a foot injury. He had been the face of the games in China, and one of few medal prospects in the track and field. Such was the Chinese hunger for success that his withdrawal made him a public hate figure.
China is not the only guilty party either. Great Britain, in its dash for Olympic success invested millions in specifically chosen events in which the GB Olympic Board felt success could be guaranteed. By investing heavily in futuristic bicycle technology, expensive yachts and shiny rowing boats the majority of GB's gold medals were achieved in elitist sports with few serious competitors. What percentage of the countries competing in the Olympics can afford to compete in events like sailing? Indeed, what percentage of the British population can afford a racing bike, kayak or shiny topper (a small racing boat, yup)? The lack of countries from Africa competing in these events highlights the lack of equality at the Beijing games.
London 2012 can be hugely successful in comparison to Beijing. But the International Olympic Committee and the GB organisers need to get their acts together. Currently only members of the Rich Man's Club are able to compete in a number of high-profile events like sailing, rowing and cycling. The number of medals on offer in these elitist sports should be halved, and more emphasis placed on track and field where all countries can compete on an equal playing field.
The Olympics also needs to regain its party atmosphere, visibly missing in China under the paranoid watchful eye of the state government. It is a cause for celebration and an opportunity for people to enjoy themselves whether they are athletes, spectators or members of the local community. This should and will happen in London.
But what the Olympic Games needs to regain most is its raison d'etre. It is an event for all countries to come together in peace and to respect each other's values and principles. This is impossible if rich nations are effectively allowed to 'buy' medals. Perhaps one way of achieving this would be to scrap official medals tables altogether and simply enjoy the occasion.
But, was it worth it? Did the Olympics justify its billion-Dollar price tag? Should China have been the host nation in the first instance? Broken promises, infringement of human rights, and lack of freedom for its people (and the journalists covering the Games) are reasons that suggest not. And of course we all know about the tragic events that have taken place in Tibet. But what is even more depressing is the vast amount of money spent on the Olympic games that could have been spent on more worthwhile causes. Yes, to stage an event as magnificent as an Olympic games requires large sums of cash, but this games broke all spending records. People were thrown from their homes, which were demolished to make way for new huge and expensive sports arenas that now lie dormant and empty and new apartment buildings were constructed for tourists that came and went, and that ordinary Chinese cannot afford.
The Olympics is traditionally a competition that has encouraged all nations to compete and come together in a friendly atmosphere. Taking part came first, winning was only a bonus. Unfortunately, more markedly in Beijing than in previous competitions winning gold medals took precedent over the art of pure competion.
Historically China has been a bastion of equality under the communist banner. In 1978 however this all changed when Deng Shaio Ping originated the Open Door Policy to foster a commercial mentality, exclaiming that 'to get rich is to get glorious'. This mentality has seeped into all areas of Chinese life, and particularly into the sports arena. China invested millions of dollars in training schemes, sports centres and coaches not to cement a sporting legacy but simply win the most gold medals, and top the medals table in 2008. This mentality even extended itself in the gymnastics arena in the form of entering fourteen year old girls with fake passports into competitions to win Golds in front of audiences around the world. Sadly, Liu Xiang was scorned and berated when he was forced to pull out of the 110 meter hurdle competition with a foot injury. He had been the face of the games in China, and one of few medal prospects in the track and field. Such was the Chinese hunger for success that his withdrawal made him a public hate figure.
China is not the only guilty party either. Great Britain, in its dash for Olympic success invested millions in specifically chosen events in which the GB Olympic Board felt success could be guaranteed. By investing heavily in futuristic bicycle technology, expensive yachts and shiny rowing boats the majority of GB's gold medals were achieved in elitist sports with few serious competitors. What percentage of the countries competing in the Olympics can afford to compete in events like sailing? Indeed, what percentage of the British population can afford a racing bike, kayak or shiny topper (a small racing boat, yup)? The lack of countries from Africa competing in these events highlights the lack of equality at the Beijing games.
London 2012 can be hugely successful in comparison to Beijing. But the International Olympic Committee and the GB organisers need to get their acts together. Currently only members of the Rich Man's Club are able to compete in a number of high-profile events like sailing, rowing and cycling. The number of medals on offer in these elitist sports should be halved, and more emphasis placed on track and field where all countries can compete on an equal playing field.
The Olympics also needs to regain its party atmosphere, visibly missing in China under the paranoid watchful eye of the state government. It is a cause for celebration and an opportunity for people to enjoy themselves whether they are athletes, spectators or members of the local community. This should and will happen in London.
But what the Olympic Games needs to regain most is its raison d'etre. It is an event for all countries to come together in peace and to respect each other's values and principles. This is impossible if rich nations are effectively allowed to 'buy' medals. Perhaps one way of achieving this would be to scrap official medals tables altogether and simply enjoy the occasion.
King Kev?
Gloomy times in Newcastle at the moment. The man who relinquished his post at Fulham, resigned from his job at Manchester City, and walked out on England has now resigned as manager of Newcastle. For the second time.
Yesterday, thousands of Newcastle fans decided to skip a day of work to stand outside St James' Park battling the torrential rain to protest Kevin Keegan's decision to leave Newcastle after citing that he was unable to work with club's owners. Keegan was effectively reduced the position of coach, and was not consulted when new faces were brought into the football club. Unsuprisingly, given his erratic history he walked out on the club.
Should Newcastle fans be dissapointed? Yes, they should be outraged by the fact that the club's owner, Mike Ashley is apparently deciding who comes and goes at St James' Park. This should be the task of the manager. But they should not be so disheartened by Keegan's exit. Is he really the Messiah Newcastle fans believe him to be? Is he even a good football manager? No he isn't. Newcastle fans should remember this is the same man who left Newcastle all those years ago, without any hint of explanation or apology. This is the man who who led Newcastle to victory in barely a third of games during his second spell at the club. Neither is Keegan a good tactician. He makes every decision with his heart. Yes he is endearing, one of the reasons Geordies warm to him so much, but he annot be relied upon to make good decisions. The fact that he protested at the board's willingless to get rid of Joey Barton emphasises this point. Barton should have gone - he can only add to Newcastle's woes. And Newcastle fans should remember that Keegan has never won a major trophy as a manager.
The statements Keegan made on leaving were disrespectful to the new players who joined the club on transfer deadline day. Keegan mocked them as he plotted his exit - God knows how they feel at this moment. It is also worth noting that the players who were brought in have performed magnificently in the opening games of the Premiership. Gutierrez and Collocini in particular have looked like great signings.
It is time for the board at Newcastle to enforce stability and lead from the top. It is time for Mike Ashley to stop wearing his XXL Newcastle shirt during mtches whilst downing lager and mingling with the fans. He is the man who now has to set an example and instill leadership at a club that quite frankly is the worst run in the Premier League. Keegan should not have been appointed in the first instance. It was a very bad decision. It is now time for Newcastle to refocus, and rebuild solid foundations at a club that needs them, particuarly in these turbulent economic times.
Newcastle United needs stability. Keegan is not the man to provide it.
Yesterday, thousands of Newcastle fans decided to skip a day of work to stand outside St James' Park battling the torrential rain to protest Kevin Keegan's decision to leave Newcastle after citing that he was unable to work with club's owners. Keegan was effectively reduced the position of coach, and was not consulted when new faces were brought into the football club. Unsuprisingly, given his erratic history he walked out on the club.
Should Newcastle fans be dissapointed? Yes, they should be outraged by the fact that the club's owner, Mike Ashley is apparently deciding who comes and goes at St James' Park. This should be the task of the manager. But they should not be so disheartened by Keegan's exit. Is he really the Messiah Newcastle fans believe him to be? Is he even a good football manager? No he isn't. Newcastle fans should remember this is the same man who left Newcastle all those years ago, without any hint of explanation or apology. This is the man who who led Newcastle to victory in barely a third of games during his second spell at the club. Neither is Keegan a good tactician. He makes every decision with his heart. Yes he is endearing, one of the reasons Geordies warm to him so much, but he annot be relied upon to make good decisions. The fact that he protested at the board's willingless to get rid of Joey Barton emphasises this point. Barton should have gone - he can only add to Newcastle's woes. And Newcastle fans should remember that Keegan has never won a major trophy as a manager.
The statements Keegan made on leaving were disrespectful to the new players who joined the club on transfer deadline day. Keegan mocked them as he plotted his exit - God knows how they feel at this moment. It is also worth noting that the players who were brought in have performed magnificently in the opening games of the Premiership. Gutierrez and Collocini in particular have looked like great signings.
It is time for the board at Newcastle to enforce stability and lead from the top. It is time for Mike Ashley to stop wearing his XXL Newcastle shirt during mtches whilst downing lager and mingling with the fans. He is the man who now has to set an example and instill leadership at a club that quite frankly is the worst run in the Premier League. Keegan should not have been appointed in the first instance. It was a very bad decision. It is now time for Newcastle to refocus, and rebuild solid foundations at a club that needs them, particuarly in these turbulent economic times.
Newcastle United needs stability. Keegan is not the man to provide it.
Football To Die For
In an era when money rules, wealthy Arabs are turning up at football clubs on a more regular basis than the weekly delivery of cornish pasties and Russian oil barons are spending their pocket money on football trophies, it is a breath of fresh air that one Premiership club has maintained some tradition and kept the club in British hands. Arsenal Football club has fought off takeover attempts from Russian billionaires and American business tycoons in the last few months as it attempts to maintain some sanity, when all around everyone seems to be going potty. Last week Manchester City was snapped up by a Middle East company with a combined wealth that outweighs even that of Roman Abramovich. Although Manchester City fans are happy, with the promise of extra transfer funds, is this takeover good for football? And is it really good for Manchester City? These are the same fans who rejoiced at the start of last season when a former Prime Minister from Thaliand bought the club and made promises he couldn't keep.
Yes, they have signed Robinho. But, did he really see himself playing for Manchester City, even an hour before he signed for the Eastands club? No. He didn't. He wanted to play for Chelsea. But then Dr Sulaiman of Abu-Dhabi United group gave him lots and lots, and a bit more money and passed him a contract and a gold pen and told him there would be more if he signed. Remember this is the player who went on strike at Santos until he forced a move to Real Madrid. Then whilst playing fot the Spanish Champions told his employers that he didn't want to play anymore, and that he was off to Chelsea. He didn't even have time to remove his dummy from his mouth before his agent told him Manchester City would pay him more than the Blues, and that is where he was going.
On the same day Manchester United spent over thirty million pounds on Dimitar Berbatov. A great footballer, but another spoilt player who decided to refuse requests from his manager to play for Tottenham and instead moaned and groaned his way out of White Hart Lane to Old Trafford.
These are sad times for English football. Money rules. Every club has adopted a 'keep up with the Jones' attitude. Even Sunderland have spent over 30 million pounds on football players in the last eight months. That is just plain ridiculous. If they are relegated, the club is effectively ruined.
Where my admiration for Arsenal grows is that its manager, Arsene Wenger refuses to be pulled in by the madness occuring around him, especially down the road at Tottenham Hotspur, a club that has spent more than treble on transfers than their nearest rivals Arsenal, but haven't come close to matching their success. Wenger has said repeatedly that he is not impressed by big names. Instead he looks for players who can adapt to the Arsenal style of play. And if they have a high price tag, they probably won't be able to. Players at the club are brought in at a young age, without egos, and are determined to learn to play with the quick deciveness and techinical ability that all Arsenal players possess. Arsenal made a profit during the transfer window last season of almost £18 million. This summer they spent what they recouped on player sales. Not bad when you consider that every other club in the premiership spent more than they recouped.
If the performance against Newcastle last weekend is replicated on a regular basis over the course of the season Arsenal will be successful despite not adding to their squad on transfer deadline day. They may not win the league, but they will certainly win over more fans playing the beautiful game the way it deserves to be played. Wenger will live or die by playing the beautiful game. But he won't spend what the club can' afford. He won't kill the club.
Yes, they have signed Robinho. But, did he really see himself playing for Manchester City, even an hour before he signed for the Eastands club? No. He didn't. He wanted to play for Chelsea. But then Dr Sulaiman of Abu-Dhabi United group gave him lots and lots, and a bit more money and passed him a contract and a gold pen and told him there would be more if he signed. Remember this is the player who went on strike at Santos until he forced a move to Real Madrid. Then whilst playing fot the Spanish Champions told his employers that he didn't want to play anymore, and that he was off to Chelsea. He didn't even have time to remove his dummy from his mouth before his agent told him Manchester City would pay him more than the Blues, and that is where he was going.
On the same day Manchester United spent over thirty million pounds on Dimitar Berbatov. A great footballer, but another spoilt player who decided to refuse requests from his manager to play for Tottenham and instead moaned and groaned his way out of White Hart Lane to Old Trafford.
These are sad times for English football. Money rules. Every club has adopted a 'keep up with the Jones' attitude. Even Sunderland have spent over 30 million pounds on football players in the last eight months. That is just plain ridiculous. If they are relegated, the club is effectively ruined.
Where my admiration for Arsenal grows is that its manager, Arsene Wenger refuses to be pulled in by the madness occuring around him, especially down the road at Tottenham Hotspur, a club that has spent more than treble on transfers than their nearest rivals Arsenal, but haven't come close to matching their success. Wenger has said repeatedly that he is not impressed by big names. Instead he looks for players who can adapt to the Arsenal style of play. And if they have a high price tag, they probably won't be able to. Players at the club are brought in at a young age, without egos, and are determined to learn to play with the quick deciveness and techinical ability that all Arsenal players possess. Arsenal made a profit during the transfer window last season of almost £18 million. This summer they spent what they recouped on player sales. Not bad when you consider that every other club in the premiership spent more than they recouped.
If the performance against Newcastle last weekend is replicated on a regular basis over the course of the season Arsenal will be successful despite not adding to their squad on transfer deadline day. They may not win the league, but they will certainly win over more fans playing the beautiful game the way it deserves to be played. Wenger will live or die by playing the beautiful game. But he won't spend what the club can' afford. He won't kill the club.
13/08/2008
Arsenal win in Holland
It will take a miracle for FC Twente to progress into the group stages of the Champions League. The Dutch side, managed by former England manager Steve McClaren suffered a home defeat at the hands of Arsenal. Only a total collapse at the Emirates Stadium in two weeks time will prevent Arsenal progressing. A young Arsenal side hampered by injuries to nine key players struggled to create chances on the night, and were lucky not to concede as Twente made their debut in the Champions League.
Mid-way through the first half FC Twente striker Arnautovic failed to control a perfectly weighted pass from the energetic Dutch midfielder Denneboom, and his weak shot was easily parried by Almunia. Denneboom had already tested Almunia with a long-range effort that seemed to swerve in mid-air and the Spanish goalkeeper was forced into making a good save. The Arsenal defence, weakened by the absence of injured Kolo Toure looked fragile, and Almunia was far the busier of the two keepers in the opening forty-five minutes.
Arsenal could have gone ahead before half time. Bacary Sagna fired wide after the Twente keeper failed to hold onto a long-range effort from Arsenal full back Gael Clichy. The ball rebounded to Sagna but his left-footed effort was a yard wide.
Arsenal showed more urgency after the break as they stepped up their efforts to grab an away goal. It came in the sixty-third minute when Gallas latched onto a Robin Van Persie free kick and managed to knock the ball past Twente keeper Boschker with his knee.
The Arsenal midfield duo of Denilson and Aaron Ramsey, making his full debut, used the ball more efficiently in the second half. However Arnautovic was presented with another opportunity to score towards the end of the match and should have equalised. With only Almunia to beat the sluggish Dutch striker hit the side netting with a poor effort.
Arsenal's superiority in the final third eventually told with ten minutes to go. A long ball from Denilson found Theo Walcott who used his electric pace to beat the Twente full back before squaring his pass to Adebayor who kept his shot low and found the back of the net.
Arsenal managed to achieve a positive result. But with the transfer deadline approaching Arsene Wenger will need to strengthen his squad if his team are win the competition proper.
Mid-way through the first half FC Twente striker Arnautovic failed to control a perfectly weighted pass from the energetic Dutch midfielder Denneboom, and his weak shot was easily parried by Almunia. Denneboom had already tested Almunia with a long-range effort that seemed to swerve in mid-air and the Spanish goalkeeper was forced into making a good save. The Arsenal defence, weakened by the absence of injured Kolo Toure looked fragile, and Almunia was far the busier of the two keepers in the opening forty-five minutes.
Arsenal could have gone ahead before half time. Bacary Sagna fired wide after the Twente keeper failed to hold onto a long-range effort from Arsenal full back Gael Clichy. The ball rebounded to Sagna but his left-footed effort was a yard wide.
Arsenal showed more urgency after the break as they stepped up their efforts to grab an away goal. It came in the sixty-third minute when Gallas latched onto a Robin Van Persie free kick and managed to knock the ball past Twente keeper Boschker with his knee.
The Arsenal midfield duo of Denilson and Aaron Ramsey, making his full debut, used the ball more efficiently in the second half. However Arnautovic was presented with another opportunity to score towards the end of the match and should have equalised. With only Almunia to beat the sluggish Dutch striker hit the side netting with a poor effort.
Arsenal's superiority in the final third eventually told with ten minutes to go. A long ball from Denilson found Theo Walcott who used his electric pace to beat the Twente full back before squaring his pass to Adebayor who kept his shot low and found the back of the net.
Arsenal managed to achieve a positive result. But with the transfer deadline approaching Arsene Wenger will need to strengthen his squad if his team are win the competition proper.
08/08/2008
Khan can fill void left by Calzaghe and Hatton
Bad news this week surfaced when Frankie Gavin had to withdraw from the British Olympic Boxing Squad. Unfortunately the young boxer was unable to consistently make the 60kg weight required to compete in the Lightweight division. Olympic boxers are required to make weight each day; for Gavin to have done so carried the risk of dehydration. This news is a hammer blow for the Olympic team; Gavin was expected to win Gold and do so in style. It is also a blow for British boxing, the Olympic squad now deprived of its brightest talent. However, the team is still overwhelmingly able, and expectations are high. Amir Khan, who brought back a Silver medal from Athens four years ago predicts a successful campaign for the British team, and a bright future for all the boxers involved. Before Gavin's withdrawal, Khan exclaimed 'we have eight boxers going out there and we have a chance to bring back eight medals. Every one of these boys is a great fighter. They are all capable and all they have to do is to stay focused'.
Khan, due to fight in early September in his nineteenth fight since turning professional struggled in his last outing against a strong, brave and more experienced fighter in the shape of Michael Gomes. The gritty Mancunian never took a backwards step during the encounter and sent Khan to the canvas in the opening rounds. However, the speed and accuracy of Khan's punches was the telling factor and a bruised and bloody Gomes was forced to retire from the contest. With a new trainer appointed into the Khan camp this week, the Bolton boxer is expected to improve his defensive technique, his Achilles heel in previous contests, whilst continuing to increase his strength and power. Jorge Rubio, a Cuban with an impressive track record and former trainer of Olympic Champion Kindelan, whom Khan defeated in his last amateur fight, will continue to train Khan in his familiar Bolton surroundings. Already, he has been impressed with Khan's enthusiasm, 'it's fantastic to be given the opportunity to work with such a natural talent like Amir and I believe that I can bring the best out in him. I'm really impressed by what I've seen of him so far and I know that we still have a lot of work to do'.
There are many similarities between Amir Khan, and Britain's most successful boxer of the last few years, Joe Calzaghe. Both men struggled in the early stages of their careers with their defensive capabilities. Both fighters like to stand with their hands held low, head leaned forward with chin slightly tucked underneath the shoulder blade. And both men possess vibrant and swift hand speed. With Calzaghe, and Ricky Hatton both fighting in the autumn in potentially the last fights of their careers, there will soon be a huge void for Khan to fill. He has the skills and technique to become the best in the world and dominate his division. And now it seems he has the trainer to help him achieve his goals and develop his obvious potential.
The future of British boxing is still bright, despite the inevitable retirements of Hatton and Calzaghe before the end of the year. Khan, and the British boxers representing Britain in Beijing can help soften this blow.
Khan, due to fight in early September in his nineteenth fight since turning professional struggled in his last outing against a strong, brave and more experienced fighter in the shape of Michael Gomes. The gritty Mancunian never took a backwards step during the encounter and sent Khan to the canvas in the opening rounds. However, the speed and accuracy of Khan's punches was the telling factor and a bruised and bloody Gomes was forced to retire from the contest. With a new trainer appointed into the Khan camp this week, the Bolton boxer is expected to improve his defensive technique, his Achilles heel in previous contests, whilst continuing to increase his strength and power. Jorge Rubio, a Cuban with an impressive track record and former trainer of Olympic Champion Kindelan, whom Khan defeated in his last amateur fight, will continue to train Khan in his familiar Bolton surroundings. Already, he has been impressed with Khan's enthusiasm, 'it's fantastic to be given the opportunity to work with such a natural talent like Amir and I believe that I can bring the best out in him. I'm really impressed by what I've seen of him so far and I know that we still have a lot of work to do'.
There are many similarities between Amir Khan, and Britain's most successful boxer of the last few years, Joe Calzaghe. Both men struggled in the early stages of their careers with their defensive capabilities. Both fighters like to stand with their hands held low, head leaned forward with chin slightly tucked underneath the shoulder blade. And both men possess vibrant and swift hand speed. With Calzaghe, and Ricky Hatton both fighting in the autumn in potentially the last fights of their careers, there will soon be a huge void for Khan to fill. He has the skills and technique to become the best in the world and dominate his division. And now it seems he has the trainer to help him achieve his goals and develop his obvious potential.
The future of British boxing is still bright, despite the inevitable retirements of Hatton and Calzaghe before the end of the year. Khan, and the British boxers representing Britain in Beijing can help soften this blow.
03/07/2008
Is the EPL becoming too strong?
One interesting aspect of the latter stages of this summer's superb European Championships was the obvious lack of Premiership stars on display.The Semi-finalists; Spain, Russia, Turkey and Germany all have one thing in common; they play without any English Premiership players. With the exception of Michael Ballack who plays for Germany and Chelsea, and Spain's Fernando Torres and Cesc Fabregas of Liverpool and Arsenal respectively, the rest of the Premiership’s elite watched the penultimate round of the competition on television. Of the 44 players who started the semi finals, only two, Ballack and Torres represent a Premiership club. For all you stats freaks out there, that's just 4.5 per cent. Not a great return since the Premier League boasts to be the most dynamic, exciting, and strongest competition in world football.But, perhaps one reason for this lack of Premiership representation at the business end of the competition is actually a direct result of the strength of the Premier League. Perhaps, the reason the Premiership wasn't represented in the same way as La Liga, the Turkcell Super League, the Bundesliga or even the Russian Premier League is because English Premiership players are physically shattered after long hard, gruelling seasons in their domestic competition. Couple that with the fantastic success of the top clubs in England in the Champions' League, a competition in which the top two in England, Chelsea and Manchester Utd reached the final, and perhaps it is not surprising that many Premiership stars ran out of legs before and during the tournament in Switzerland and Austria. The physical nature of the Premier League is also possibly the main factor in England’s inability to even qualify for the tournament.There is no doubting that last year's domestic competition was stronger than any previous year in history. The dominance of British clubs in European competition was impressive, especially in comparison to the unusually poor performances by teams from Spain, and in particular Italy. The ease with which Arsenal dismantled AC Milan was petrifying. And Manchester United’s progression into the final was frightening. Barcelona and Roma were pushed aside with apparent ease.Real Madrid, a club that supplied Spain with the backbone of their team performed atrociously in this season's Champions' League. Knocked out by Roma in the Quarter Final stage, Madrid were able to rest players and literally stroll to a victory in La Liga. Barcelona failed to push them all the way, and could only manage a third place finish behind a relatively weak Villarreal side.Spain were truly magnificent in conquering Europe and determining that the Henri Delaunay Trophy would rest gloriously in Madrid for the next four years. They certainly played the most attractive football in the competition, and looked to score and create chances in every game. But, perhaps their success was also a result of the relative weakness of the Spanish Championship and poor performances by Spanish teams in European competition. The positive effect this had on the national side in the form of rest for the players, both physically and mentally is undeniable.The success and strength of the Premiership is great for spectators and fans. Every game is contested. But perhaps the pace and tempo of EPL games is playing a detrimental role for national sides with a wealth of Premier League stars. We only need to look at Sweden's dire performance against Russia in the Quarter-final stage. The players, most of whom ply their trade in England's top division, looked physically drained, and were visibly dismantled by a fresher, and more energetic Russian side.The solution is a reduction in the number of teams in the EPL from 20 to 18 sides, following the examples of the French, German and Spanish governing bodies. This reduction in teams would ease the heavy schedule in England and enable the players to enjoy a Christmas break.If we want to see England qualify for the World Cup in 2010, and more Premiership players contesting major finals, the gap that seems to be widening between the Premiership and other European Leagues needs to close. And soon.
30/06/2008
Desert Skin
The ground is dry,
Calling for rain,
Cracks like wrinkles,
I'm in so much pain,
honey,
Ripped my heart from inside my cage,
Infuriated,
Sick with rage,
Look at you,
That smile on your face,
I don't laugh at all these days,
No fruit grows on my trees,
Dry, tasteless, lightning,
Puts me on my knees,
Nothing can bring you back,
honey,
Days remembered with a sick fondness,
Me, you, us,
Gone,
Turned to dust,
Like desert skin.
Calling for rain,
Cracks like wrinkles,
I'm in so much pain,
honey,
Ripped my heart from inside my cage,
Infuriated,
Sick with rage,
Look at you,
That smile on your face,
I don't laugh at all these days,
No fruit grows on my trees,
Dry, tasteless, lightning,
Puts me on my knees,
Nothing can bring you back,
honey,
Days remembered with a sick fondness,
Me, you, us,
Gone,
Turned to dust,
Like desert skin.
21/06/2008
Calzaghe Reigns Supreme in Las Vegas

Joe Calzaghe achieved his American Dream yesterday and cemented his legacy as the best British boxer of his generation as he defeated Bernard Hopkins on a split points decision in front of 14,000 fans at the Thomas and Mack Centre in Las Vegas. It was a spectacular victory considering it was Calzaghe's first fight in the US, and his first as a light-heavy weight. The fact that Calzaghe had to rise from the canvas after just ninety seconds makes this victory all the more impressive. Hopkins unleashed a vicious right hook mid-way through the opening round that toppled Calzaghe for only the third time in his forty-five fight career as a professional. Calzaghe looked stunned, but in the fashion of a true champion, he was able to rise to his feet, and outbox the 'Executioner' Hopkins, particularly in the latter rounds to claim victory on two of the judges score cards and secure the most prestigious win of his illustrious fifteen year career.
There is no doubt that this was certainly Calzaghe's toughest fight to date. He struggled to cope with Hopkins’s tactic of fighting on the inside, and was unable to make use of either his left jab, or his famed hand speed. Hopkins is a defensive master, and he frustrated his Welsh opponent throughout the contest by refusing to come forward, instead preferring to attack on the counter. Calzaghe dropped his hands in an attempt to draw the 'Executioner' into a boxing fight, but Hopkins was far more savvy that any of Joe's previous opponents and remained on the back foot, throwing accurate punches and landing the cleaner shots throughout. ‘I didn't box as well as I could, it was bit messy’, Calzaghe said ‘Hopkins was very dirty on the inside. But I fought at a new weight for the first time, got put down and still managed to win. I'm very proud, I came to America to fight, and to win’.
In defeating Hopkins in front of a star-studded audience, Calzaghe won the much respected world light-heavy-weight title as recognised by the Ring magazine, and is now just four victories short of Rocky Marciano's forty-nine victory record. The Newbridge boxer is Britain's longest reigning world champion. Recently awarded BBC Sport's Personality of the Year, he is at last winning the accolades and respect he deserves. Acknowledged as one of the best pound-for-pound fighters in the world, Calzaghe entered the ring as heavy favourite. But he couldn't have got off to a worse start. Disaster struck when Hopkins landed a heavy right to Calzaghe's nose in the second minute of the bout. Calzaghe was cut, and visibly shaken. In his first fight in the Nevada desert, Calzaghe was too relaxed during the opening exchanges, he dropped his hands, and got too close to Hopkins, who was able to catch the Welshman with a wicked right hand that sent him crashing to the canvas. Hopkins was unable to take proper advantage however. His forty-three years prevented him launching an onslaught after the knockdown that may have prevented the dazed and confused Calzaghe continuing. Instead, Hopkins was only able to throw one more decent shot in the opening round. Nevertheless the judges scored the first round 10-8 to Hopkins.
Rounds two and three told similar stories. Hopkins continued to hold Calzaghe when they got close in an attempt to slow the fight down, and prevent Calzaghe operating at a fast tempo. Hopkins continually fought on the back foot inviting Calzaghe to fight up close, which allowed him to demonstrate his greater strength in the grappling that ensued and dominated the opening rounds. Despite the ''Wales, Wales'' chants that echoed around the arena at the end of the third, Calzaghe looked subdued as he trounced back towards to his father, and trainer, Enzo, in his corner.
The fourth round was very scrappy, and Hopkins continually led with his head, which forced a warning from the referee, Joe Cortez. But, this was a better round for Calzaghe who was able to land a good left jab in the last ten seconds, and raised the volume in the crowd by lifting his arms into the air on the bell. Calzaghe's confidence was markedly growing, and he landed his best punch of the fight, a hard left during the opening exchanges in the fifth. Even at this early stage, Hopkins looked to be tiring, and it was Calzaghe who was controlling the tempo of the fight. Despite losing the sixth round, Calzaghe came back in the seventh with some good combinations to the torso of Hopkins. However, a frustrated Calzaghe was still unable to fight at a pace that suited him and Hopkins continued to grapple in the middle of the ring thereby continually decreasing the tempo of the fight.
The Welsh National anthem welcomed Calzaghe as he exited his corner at the beginning of the eighth, the liveliest round of the fight. Calzaghe was able to land a clean right, but Hopkins retaliated with a great right of his own, and Enzo could be heard warning his son that he needed to up the tempo and land more combinations of punches. By the ninth, Hopkins was visibly becoming tired. His mouth gaped wide open as he gasped for oxygen under the mass of blurry lights above his head, and Calzaghe was finally able to break through Hopkins marvellous defence, and hurt his opponent for the first time in the contest. With two rounds remaining, the American Hopkins showed off his talent for gamesmanship and claimed a phantom low blow. Despite TV replays indicating that the shot was fair, the referee allowed Hopkins over four minutes to recover. The infuriated crowd taunted Hopkins with growls of ''cheat cheat'' as he returned to action in a stand off with Calzaghe in the centre of the ring. The recovery time afforded to Hopkins enabled him to take a breather away from the action and he looked rejuvenated, landing a flurry of blows to Calzaghe’s chin that enabled him to nick the tenth. The eleventh and penultimate round was dramatic, and Hopkins claimed another low blow. This time the referee justifiably ignored it, before Calzaghe landed an accomplished right at the end of the round.
In a gripping final round, Calzaghe threw more punches than his exhausted opponent, and looked far more energetic and active as he moved around the ring. Hopkins stood back as he had done all fight, and invited Calzaghe forward. As the final bell sounded, both fighters became engaged in a brawl in the middle of the ring, before raising their arms to claim victory.
Although Calzaghe’s performance was scrappy, it would have been an injustice if he had not been awarded victory. He out boxed his opponent, and threw over a hundred more punches over twelve disjointed rounds. The man from Newbridge finished the stronger, and made sure of his victory by upping his work rate in the final rounds. Sweaty, bruised, but relieved, Calzaghe said ''after six or seven rounds I felt him struggling. He couldn’t handle the pace so he took a rest and the referee allowed it. I feel very proud of what I've achieved. When I turned pro with my dad as my trainer people laughed. But now we've shown them''. This was Calzaghe's night. Victory in America is a dream no longer.
There is no doubt that this was certainly Calzaghe's toughest fight to date. He struggled to cope with Hopkins’s tactic of fighting on the inside, and was unable to make use of either his left jab, or his famed hand speed. Hopkins is a defensive master, and he frustrated his Welsh opponent throughout the contest by refusing to come forward, instead preferring to attack on the counter. Calzaghe dropped his hands in an attempt to draw the 'Executioner' into a boxing fight, but Hopkins was far more savvy that any of Joe's previous opponents and remained on the back foot, throwing accurate punches and landing the cleaner shots throughout. ‘I didn't box as well as I could, it was bit messy’, Calzaghe said ‘Hopkins was very dirty on the inside. But I fought at a new weight for the first time, got put down and still managed to win. I'm very proud, I came to America to fight, and to win’.
In defeating Hopkins in front of a star-studded audience, Calzaghe won the much respected world light-heavy-weight title as recognised by the Ring magazine, and is now just four victories short of Rocky Marciano's forty-nine victory record. The Newbridge boxer is Britain's longest reigning world champion. Recently awarded BBC Sport's Personality of the Year, he is at last winning the accolades and respect he deserves. Acknowledged as one of the best pound-for-pound fighters in the world, Calzaghe entered the ring as heavy favourite. But he couldn't have got off to a worse start. Disaster struck when Hopkins landed a heavy right to Calzaghe's nose in the second minute of the bout. Calzaghe was cut, and visibly shaken. In his first fight in the Nevada desert, Calzaghe was too relaxed during the opening exchanges, he dropped his hands, and got too close to Hopkins, who was able to catch the Welshman with a wicked right hand that sent him crashing to the canvas. Hopkins was unable to take proper advantage however. His forty-three years prevented him launching an onslaught after the knockdown that may have prevented the dazed and confused Calzaghe continuing. Instead, Hopkins was only able to throw one more decent shot in the opening round. Nevertheless the judges scored the first round 10-8 to Hopkins.
Rounds two and three told similar stories. Hopkins continued to hold Calzaghe when they got close in an attempt to slow the fight down, and prevent Calzaghe operating at a fast tempo. Hopkins continually fought on the back foot inviting Calzaghe to fight up close, which allowed him to demonstrate his greater strength in the grappling that ensued and dominated the opening rounds. Despite the ''Wales, Wales'' chants that echoed around the arena at the end of the third, Calzaghe looked subdued as he trounced back towards to his father, and trainer, Enzo, in his corner.
The fourth round was very scrappy, and Hopkins continually led with his head, which forced a warning from the referee, Joe Cortez. But, this was a better round for Calzaghe who was able to land a good left jab in the last ten seconds, and raised the volume in the crowd by lifting his arms into the air on the bell. Calzaghe's confidence was markedly growing, and he landed his best punch of the fight, a hard left during the opening exchanges in the fifth. Even at this early stage, Hopkins looked to be tiring, and it was Calzaghe who was controlling the tempo of the fight. Despite losing the sixth round, Calzaghe came back in the seventh with some good combinations to the torso of Hopkins. However, a frustrated Calzaghe was still unable to fight at a pace that suited him and Hopkins continued to grapple in the middle of the ring thereby continually decreasing the tempo of the fight.
The Welsh National anthem welcomed Calzaghe as he exited his corner at the beginning of the eighth, the liveliest round of the fight. Calzaghe was able to land a clean right, but Hopkins retaliated with a great right of his own, and Enzo could be heard warning his son that he needed to up the tempo and land more combinations of punches. By the ninth, Hopkins was visibly becoming tired. His mouth gaped wide open as he gasped for oxygen under the mass of blurry lights above his head, and Calzaghe was finally able to break through Hopkins marvellous defence, and hurt his opponent for the first time in the contest. With two rounds remaining, the American Hopkins showed off his talent for gamesmanship and claimed a phantom low blow. Despite TV replays indicating that the shot was fair, the referee allowed Hopkins over four minutes to recover. The infuriated crowd taunted Hopkins with growls of ''cheat cheat'' as he returned to action in a stand off with Calzaghe in the centre of the ring. The recovery time afforded to Hopkins enabled him to take a breather away from the action and he looked rejuvenated, landing a flurry of blows to Calzaghe’s chin that enabled him to nick the tenth. The eleventh and penultimate round was dramatic, and Hopkins claimed another low blow. This time the referee justifiably ignored it, before Calzaghe landed an accomplished right at the end of the round.
In a gripping final round, Calzaghe threw more punches than his exhausted opponent, and looked far more energetic and active as he moved around the ring. Hopkins stood back as he had done all fight, and invited Calzaghe forward. As the final bell sounded, both fighters became engaged in a brawl in the middle of the ring, before raising their arms to claim victory.
Although Calzaghe’s performance was scrappy, it would have been an injustice if he had not been awarded victory. He out boxed his opponent, and threw over a hundred more punches over twelve disjointed rounds. The man from Newbridge finished the stronger, and made sure of his victory by upping his work rate in the final rounds. Sweaty, bruised, but relieved, Calzaghe said ''after six or seven rounds I felt him struggling. He couldn’t handle the pace so he took a rest and the referee allowed it. I feel very proud of what I've achieved. When I turned pro with my dad as my trainer people laughed. But now we've shown them''. This was Calzaghe's night. Victory in America is a dream no longer.
18/06/2008
Boxing is far better than playing Cricket

Recently I had an argument with a friend. He is a cricketer. He had a very serious expression of disappointment on his face when I claimed that cricket was not a sport, but in fact, simply a game. And not a very good one at that. I shuffled backwards when I thought he was going to hit me, which led to me inform him that boxing is a better sport. He scoffed in a very cricket-like way when I said this. And, so I told him I would prove it by writing it down.Every Saturday morning (only in the summer of course, and when it isn't raining and the weather man comes on TV with his smiley face and promises it definitely won’t be raining) he strolls down to the local cricket field where he puts on multiple layers of white/beige clothing. He wears white trousers that look like they are made of cheap imitation silk. And he puts on a thick white woolly jumper. It is so thick a whole sheep has definitely been used in the process of making it. He only puts on his trousers after he has carefully placed a white (of course) plastic box over his groin area. This I am told is to protect his crown jewels from the solid red circular piece of wood, in the shape of a ball, that they 'bowl' at each other. He then covers his face in factor two-hundred and fifty, and folds wraparound sunglasses over his eyes. A Royal Marine in Iraq wears less protection during an ambush.I have watched him play once. I arrived at the ground early in the morning. The sun's rays were strong, but the woolly jumpers prevailed. A team of men and boys ranging from the ages of 14 and 144 jogged onto the pitch. As far as I could tell, at least fifty per cent of the 'fielding' team were clinically obese. And whilst watching the game I understood why. Nobody moved. Every player just stood still absolutely motionless, admiring the aeroplanes overhead, occasionally watching the bowler throw a ball towards the stumps strategically positioned behind the batsman (donned in white jumper and metal helmet of course). I couldn't help thinking 'what is the point of this?...Do these guys actually find this fun?...Do the spectators enjoy spending their weekends watching amateur cricketers stand around as if they forgot to move when someone told them the grass was being covered with tarmac, picking their noses, day dreaming about what else they could be doing on a sunny day in august?'. Surely even 'Country Life is more exciting'? But, then it became obvious. These guys don't actually enjoy watching or playing cricket. They enjoy the male company that comes with being part of a team, or spectators of the local cricket team. It is often asserted that there are no homosexual footballers. This always seemed very strange to me, since one in ten men are apparently gay. But, now it makes sense. They all play cricket. They bat for the other team. On Saturday mornings.There are no women at cricket games. Even the 'tea-lady' was male. I think. Every one who plays is normally very middle class. It is after all a gentleman's game. They are all white, and are balding (even the twenty-year olds). I don't like cricket. And I don't love it either. It is one of those British pastimes that claims sport stattus, one that we invented, but aren't any good at. That only a handful of countries around the world bother to play is testament to its pathetic nature. Secretly, including those that play it, nobody really enjoys cricket. Even commentators sigh at having to pretend to be excited watching a bunch of homesexual South Africans stand around on a field, occasioanlly screaming 'He's out', and then hugging each other when a piece of wood falls over.Boxing, on the other hand is a true and popular sport. Boxing fans really do appreciate its uniqueness and the skills involved. Nobody comes to watch boxing to drink tea and chat about the weather. Boxing as we know it today has emerged, but not changed much from the London Prize Ring Rules of the late eighteenth century. Admitedly, after a dull patch in the last couple of years, it is a sport that has experienced a recent surge in popularity especially in Britain, in part due to the successes of excellent British boxers like Joe Calzaghe, David Haye, and in particular the very likeable Ricky Hatton. It has also managed to fend off rival sports in the US, including MMA (Mixed Martial Arts) and cemented its position as the number one combat sport in the world. In Mexico, Mexican boxers are treated like Gods. In America, boxers are saluted in their home states as heroes, and in the Philippines, Manny Pacquiao is more popular than God.I like boxing, because it promotes respect. Ask anybody who has stepped into a ring if it has taught him or her to respect an opponent and they will answer in a firm toned, straight-eyes, very positive single syllabed ‘Yes’. Once you have been beaten up in the ring, you immediately find yourself to be a more humbled homosapien. You begin to respect everyone, teachers, parents, peers, no matter where they are from, regardless of colour, religion or creed. I have a cousin who boxes in Northern Ireland. The first thing he learned was that there was no sectarianism in the boxing gym. Any segregation that existed in the fractious communities in Belfast didn’t exist in the West Belfast Boxing gym. Boxing enabled black men in 50s and 60s America to achieve success and superstar status in a racist, divisive community. Joe Louis, the first African-American Heavy weight Champion of the World became a national hero, and cememnted his legendary status by representing his country, when he didn't have to, in World War Two.Boxing also promotes physical fitness. 'Super-fit' is about the only word capable of describing a boxer primed for a fight. Unlike cricketers, boxers train endlessly in an attempt to be at their peak level of fitness come fight night. To be anything less than at full fitness not only reduces your chances of success in the ring, but can lead to inury too. That is not to say boxing is a dangerous sport. It isn't. Protective head gear and the excellent training and supervision offered by dedicated coaches up and down the country mean boxing is as safe, if not safer than other sports.As a spectacle boxing is far superior to cricket in terms of enjoyment and entertainment. I can honestly say that I have never sat down and watched a cricket game and then come away enthralled at what I have just witnessed. It is almost a chore having to watch a game of cricket. It cannot provide the same sort of enjoyment or arouse passionate emotions like a boxing fight can. I genuinely can't count the number of times I have sat and watched a boxing fight, unable to remain calm and seated on my chair. The emotions it arouses watching two men at the peak of their sport challenge each other in the ring. It is as Roy Keane once exclaimed, 'the pinnacle of sport - one on one combat, with nobody to help you in there, except yourself'.Recently I was lucky enough to find myself in Las Vegas to watch Joe Calzaghe defeat one of the greatest boxers of his generation, Bernard Hopkins. The atmosphere in the Planet Hollywood arena was electric. With every punch thrown, the crowd ooed and awed, appreciating the skill and technique on display. Calzaghe won in front of a star-studded audience and we all (with the exception of Hopkins) went home happy and satisfied.My friend, boxing is certainly better than cricket.
31/05/2007
Better Luck Next Time!

Thank god it’s over. This has been the least fruitful of all seasons for Arsenal since I started supporting the Gunners as an eight year old boy. I’m pretty lucky I chose Arsenal back then; it was either Arsenal or Tottenham. Or West Ham. I'm twenty now and I’ve been pretty lucky in terms of seeing my club actually win things rather than having to resort to getting excited about finishing the season in mid table mediocrity, or even worse like Hammers fans I’ve grown up with, having to watch my team stave or relegation, or even worse - get relegated.
But with success comes expectation and hope. I have seen Arsenal win trophies; I was at Highbury when Adams lifted the trophy in 1998 and 2002, and when Vieira lifted the Premiership trophy as captain of the ‘unbeatables’ in 2004. Its 2007 now, and I haven’t seen Arsenal win anything since (except the FA Cup in 2005 - which, incidentally we didn’t deserve!)
At least last season, despite an appalling season in which Tottenham would have pipped us to the fourth and final Champions league place had they not been infamously poisoned by some bad chefs, we reached the European cup final. This year us Arsenal fans have had practically nothing to shout about. In fact since March most Arsenal fans I know couldn’t have cared less about the Premiership, or the FA cup, or the European cup for that matter ‘cos we weren’t competing in any of them! After the defeat at the hands of Chelsea in Cardiff in the last Carling Cup Final top be played at the Millennium (before it returns to Wembley next year) there followed for the gunners a succession of defeats that saw them knocked out of every competition going!
Still, there is hope - our team is young. Very young. In fact the average age of the team I suspect is younger than me! But, there comes a time when you start to sound stupid when you’re repeatedly telling friends who support Liverpool, Chelsea or Man Utd that you’re better than them ‘cos you’re players are younger and destined for success in the future! Still tho, I’d rather pay money to watch Arsenal than Liverpool or Chelsea. Arsene Wenger’s philosophy of keeping the ball on the floor and playing ‘pretty’ football is nice on the eye, especially when compared to Liverpool and Chelsea tactics, which normally consist of ‘hoofing’ the ball up field to the muscular giants Drogba and Kuyt. This certainly holds no appeal for me nor I would hope any football fan!
Indeed, our strikers prefer it to be played to feet. But unfortunately neither Van Persie nor Henry managed to play much football this season. Since Christmas neither player managed to play more than a handful of games, and this is probably where our season began to fall apart. Add to their long term injuries that picked up by Gallas, yet to really get his Arsenal career under way, and it is clear where things started to go wrong.
But all clubs experience injuries (look at Newcastle!) and you cant make excuses. This is where you need a competent squad and I don’t feel Arsenal have one. As I’ve mentioned, the squad is young. Too young. Players like Denilson, Walcott and Diaby are good, but they don’t have the experience to step into a struggling team and make a difference. Instead Arsenal needed more experienced players to fill the voids left by the more experienced injured players.
And this is where the solution lies. In the summer, I hope Wenger makes at least three ‘big’ signings. Experienced players, who have proved they can perform on the big stage and withstand the physical battles they will experience at places like Man City, Fulham and West Ham (all places Arsenal lost this season).
Still Arsenal did finish top of the ‘big four’ league, and managed to defeat the Champions, Manchester United home and away. Let’s hope the Gunners finish top of the league proper next season. Fingers crossed!
06/05/2007
Las Vegas Showdown
The Las Vegas strip was intriguingly quiet last night between the hours of 11 and 12. Many gamblers opted to pay vast sums of money to watch a boxing fight on large screens inside the many hotels and casinos that inhabit the isolated desert strip rather than invest their money in slot machines and roulette tables. One hotel was busier than most last night. The MGM grand, famous for its rich history in hosting a wealth of memorable boxing bouts, was the scene once more for an enthralling fight between two of the sport’s most famous and well known stars. In the richest fight in boxing history, expected to gross over £60 million, the ‘Golden Boy’ Oscar De La Hoya was defeated on a split decision by the judge’s scorecards by arguably the best pound-for-pound fighter in the world, ’Pretty Boy’ Floyd Mayweather.
De La Hoya, also a very successful promoter and co-owner of Golden Boy Productions, who hosted last night’s event, entered the ring almost a stone heavier than his opponent, who stepped up a weight division to contest De La Hoya’s Super Welterweight title. Significantly though, De La Hoya, at 34 years of age is four years older than the ‘Pretty Boy’, and many, including Mayweather, predicted that De La Hoya would tire in the latter rounds. The bookies agreed, and made Mayweather a clear odds on favourite.
Mayweather’s confidence before the fight has been obvious in his insulting rants and dismissal of De La Hoya‘s chances, and he made a typically confident entrance to the ring, dressed in Mexican colours (De La Hoya is of Mexican origin) and accompanied by rap star 50 Cent. But the stars at ringside, including Jack Nicholson, Leonardo Di Caprio and Jennifer Lopez were all supporting the popular De La Hoya, and the 16,5000 crowd rose to rapturous applaud as he made a more orthodox entrance to the ring. Indeed, if this fight was a popularity contest De La Hoya had a comfortable victory in the beckoning.
Unfortunately for the ‘Golden Boy’ boxing results are not measured in terms of popularity, and when proceedings got under way Mayweather looked the more comfortable fighter. In the first round he was able to duck and dive under De La Hoya’s stronger, but slower punches, whilst delivering accurate shots to the head and body of De La Hoya. However, the ‘Golden Boy’s’ determination to win this fight was obvious in the second round, which he clearly won. His expression was one of concentration, and he held the centre of the ring, delivering flurries of blows to Mayweather’s ripped torso. But De La Hoya’s greater age was telling, even in the first few rounds and he was unable to deliver punches in more than ten second bursts. Mayweather had warned De La Hoya before the fight ‘there ain’t no gas pumps in there’ and he was evidently saving his energy for the latter stages of the fight.
Nevertheless, De La Hoya was the one making the moves in the first few rounds, and although his punches weren’t hurting Mayweather, they were landing and he was winning the points. Mayweather’s corner reacted and harsh words at the end of the fourth inspired a rejuvenated Mayweather to win a decisive fifth round. The skill and pace of Mayweather were telling, and a sharp right hand knocked De La Hoya back at the bell.
In the sixth the ‘Golden Boy’ was able deliver a succession of blows upon his opponent, but Mayweather was winning the rounds with smart and precise shots. The next four rounds adopted a similar pattern and Mayweather’s boxing superiority was emphasised by cleaner, quicker rights and left hooks.
In the final round, both fighters delivered a superb show, and De La Hoya was the more aggressive after losing the two previous rounds. He gave everything he had left in the tank, and at the final bell both fighters were swinging wildly.
At the final bell, the crowd was chanting De La Hoya’s name, but nobody knew how the judges would score the fight. Mayweather had dominated in the final stages, but De La Hoya was certainly the more aggressive fighter in the early rounds, and his more aggressive tactics could have swayed the judges opinion. Both fighters were confident of victory. In the end, two judges scored the fight in favour of Mayweather, and he retained his unbeaten record of 38 victories. Clearly disappointed De La Hoya exclaimed afterwards ‘I was pressing and wanted to stop him. I was trying to close the show. I am the champion and you've got to do more than that to beat the champion’.
De La Hoya has a point. But on the night, swiftness, speed and rapidity defeated strength and power. Not everybody agreed with the decision, but everyone was in agreement that both men put on an exciting show. Boxing which has suffered falling viewing figures, needed a big fight. Screened in 176 countries this wasn’t a classic by any means, but it was exciting and riveting, and certainly put boxing back on the map.
Joseph Lappin
06/05/04
De La Hoya, also a very successful promoter and co-owner of Golden Boy Productions, who hosted last night’s event, entered the ring almost a stone heavier than his opponent, who stepped up a weight division to contest De La Hoya’s Super Welterweight title. Significantly though, De La Hoya, at 34 years of age is four years older than the ‘Pretty Boy’, and many, including Mayweather, predicted that De La Hoya would tire in the latter rounds. The bookies agreed, and made Mayweather a clear odds on favourite.
Mayweather’s confidence before the fight has been obvious in his insulting rants and dismissal of De La Hoya‘s chances, and he made a typically confident entrance to the ring, dressed in Mexican colours (De La Hoya is of Mexican origin) and accompanied by rap star 50 Cent. But the stars at ringside, including Jack Nicholson, Leonardo Di Caprio and Jennifer Lopez were all supporting the popular De La Hoya, and the 16,5000 crowd rose to rapturous applaud as he made a more orthodox entrance to the ring. Indeed, if this fight was a popularity contest De La Hoya had a comfortable victory in the beckoning.
Unfortunately for the ‘Golden Boy’ boxing results are not measured in terms of popularity, and when proceedings got under way Mayweather looked the more comfortable fighter. In the first round he was able to duck and dive under De La Hoya’s stronger, but slower punches, whilst delivering accurate shots to the head and body of De La Hoya. However, the ‘Golden Boy’s’ determination to win this fight was obvious in the second round, which he clearly won. His expression was one of concentration, and he held the centre of the ring, delivering flurries of blows to Mayweather’s ripped torso. But De La Hoya’s greater age was telling, even in the first few rounds and he was unable to deliver punches in more than ten second bursts. Mayweather had warned De La Hoya before the fight ‘there ain’t no gas pumps in there’ and he was evidently saving his energy for the latter stages of the fight.
Nevertheless, De La Hoya was the one making the moves in the first few rounds, and although his punches weren’t hurting Mayweather, they were landing and he was winning the points. Mayweather’s corner reacted and harsh words at the end of the fourth inspired a rejuvenated Mayweather to win a decisive fifth round. The skill and pace of Mayweather were telling, and a sharp right hand knocked De La Hoya back at the bell.
In the sixth the ‘Golden Boy’ was able deliver a succession of blows upon his opponent, but Mayweather was winning the rounds with smart and precise shots. The next four rounds adopted a similar pattern and Mayweather’s boxing superiority was emphasised by cleaner, quicker rights and left hooks.
In the final round, both fighters delivered a superb show, and De La Hoya was the more aggressive after losing the two previous rounds. He gave everything he had left in the tank, and at the final bell both fighters were swinging wildly.
At the final bell, the crowd was chanting De La Hoya’s name, but nobody knew how the judges would score the fight. Mayweather had dominated in the final stages, but De La Hoya was certainly the more aggressive fighter in the early rounds, and his more aggressive tactics could have swayed the judges opinion. Both fighters were confident of victory. In the end, two judges scored the fight in favour of Mayweather, and he retained his unbeaten record of 38 victories. Clearly disappointed De La Hoya exclaimed afterwards ‘I was pressing and wanted to stop him. I was trying to close the show. I am the champion and you've got to do more than that to beat the champion’.
De La Hoya has a point. But on the night, swiftness, speed and rapidity defeated strength and power. Not everybody agreed with the decision, but everyone was in agreement that both men put on an exciting show. Boxing which has suffered falling viewing figures, needed a big fight. Screened in 176 countries this wasn’t a classic by any means, but it was exciting and riveting, and certainly put boxing back on the map.
Joseph Lappin
06/05/04
03/05/2007
Boxing's Saviour?

Oscar De La Hoya’s eagerly anticipated showdown with Floyd Mayweather is being described as the saviour of Boxing, at a time when the sport is being criticised for too many ‘poor’ and boring displays, too many World title belts that mean there is no recognised champion in each weight division and a lack of colourful characters. And all this criticism when another sport, Ultimate Fighting, better known as UFC is threatening to lure away even the most avid and fanatic boxing fans.
On 5 May, two of the most recognised figures in the sport will step into a ring together in Las Vegas, at the MGM Grand, scene of some of the most enthralling boxing fights, hoping to deliver one of the most exciting bouts in boxing history. Without this kind of match up many in the boxing scene are worried about the sport's future.
Despite the pessimism surrounding the sport at the moment, even Mayweather arguing that 'boxing needs this fight', many in the boxing circuit insist the future of boxing is bright. Frank Maloney, one of the most successful promoters Britain has produced maintains that UFC is ‘just a fad’ and that with time any boxing fans that have switched their allegiance to the UFC scene will return.
And, in terms of numbers boxing has never been as big. More and more people are taking up boxing, either as a hobby, or as part of a desire to learn to fight. Four months ago I began boxing myself, and am now totally obsessed by the sport. Boxing teaches discipline, respect, and of course makes you very, very fit. I have played football for a number of teams over the years, but have never felt pain like that during a boxing session. Even Roy Keane, who had three amateur bouts a s a teenager admits ‘Boxing is sport in its truest form’. As a sporting entity, the Government has also seen the positive elements boxing instils in children, and has recently promoted a campaign in inner city London schools to encourage children to adopt the sport. The 'Boxing in Schools' programme has been extremely successful so far with numerous schools in the Capital endorsing the project, and it is hoped that over the next few years schools all over the country will embrace the project.
I’m not so sure Boxing really needs a saviour. There are still so many world class fighters out there providing entertainment to millions, with Britain’s Joe Calzaghe and Ricky Hatton providing just two such examples. One thing is for sure however, De La Hoya and Mayweather will put on an exhilarating show, and any non-boxing fans watching will surely be converted into boxing fanatics that night.
26/04/2007
Assess the economic record of the 1974-79 Labour Governments
The mid 1970s argues Jim Tomlinson ‘are commonly seen as a watershed in post-war economic policy’. The decade was host to a crises over public spending and borrowing and the exchange rate. It witnessed industrial dispute and the failure of the Social Contract. This was the decade that saw Keynesian economic theory quashed by the arrival of stagflation. The assessment of economic policy of the government in the period, argues Christopher Allsopp, has been critical, ‘regarded as a failure by the left and as a disaster by the right’. Thatcher’s Conservative Government of the 1980s vociferously criticised Labour’s management of the economy, to emphasise their own ‘safe-hands’ approach. Contemporary journalists too, were extremely critical of Labour’s economic record. The Economist magazine suggested in 1975, that Britain’s economic position was so bad that, ‘Britannia’s dream of apocalypse is horribly close to coming true’. After five years in power, the infamous ‘Winter of Discontent’, which was a direct result of Labour’s unpopular pay policy enforced upon Trade Unions was a huge factor in ending Labour’s reign in Government. In the 1979 election, the Conservatives achieved a landslide victory.
Wilson’s Labour Party assumed power from Heath’s Conservatives, on 4 March 1974 on the brink of the most testing economic crisis experienced for over two decades and in circumstances of industrial turmoil and political uncertainty. Tomlinson describes labour’s economic inheritance as a ‘poisoned chalice’. The Heath Government had embarked on an expansionary fiscal and monetary policy, and initiated the Heath-Barber boom, a strategy of creating and sustaining a high level of aggregate demand in the hope of encouraging a great leap in industrial development, with favourable effects on productivity and growth. And although unemployment fell as a result of the boom, inflation increased from under 7 per cent in 1972, to a rate of over 10 per cent in late 1973. The boom also caused a sterling crisis in June 1972, the floating of the Pound and subsequent depreciation in the exchange rate. Heath and his cabinet were forced to raise interest rates to record levels and cut its public spending. Heath’s position deteriorated further, when the National Union of Miners called a strike on 12 November 1973, just as the oil crisis, which saw oil prices quadruple, hit Britain. Allsopp insists, ‘the legacy of the Heath government’s dash for growth combined with the first oil crisis meant that the starting point’ for Labour ‘was one of extraordinary difficulty’. The industrial relations crisis with the miners effectively brought Heath’s period in office to an end. The miner’s dispute, combined with a reduction in oil supply, led to a three-day working week being imposed on industry to save energy. At the same time wage inflation was rocketing, and Heath’s attempts to control it with the policy of threshold agreements failed. With the manufacturing industry in Britain in turmoil, Heath decided to call an election on the theme of ‘Who Rules?’ Heath was defeated, in an election in which neither the Conservatives nor Labour did well. The Labour Party was handed the task of forming the next government, ‘albeit without the mandate of an overall majority, for the election resulted in a hung Parliament’. Nevertheless, Labour was the largest party, and arrived in Government with inflation higher than in 1970 when the Conservatives took office, the balance of payments in the red and the exchange rate sinking quickly. The public sector deficit was at a peacetime high and Tomlinson agrees, ‘when Labour took office almost every economic indicator was moving adversely’.
Wilson’s aim when he first arrived at Downing Street, was to solve the immediate crisis with the National Union of Miners, and he swiftly ended the strike by granting the miner’s demands, thus putting an end to the three-day working week. Action was quickly begun to repeal and replace Heath’s detested Industrial relations Act. When Labour was in opposition, they promised the electorate that they could solve the problems with the unions that had marred Heath’s period in office, and indeed Wilson’s earlier period as Prime Minister between 1966-70. James Cronin, describes Labour’s agreement with the unions, the Social Contract, as a ‘deal in which the party agreed to refrain from statutory incomes policy while in office, to restore and augment Union rights, and most importantly, to use the powers of the state to increase the social wage in the hope that unions would respond by moderating wage claims, and where possible, discouraging the resort to strikes’. Robert Taylor adds, the Social Contract aimed to ‘establish a much closer relationship with the Trade Unions that would prevent any repetition of the kind of trouble that had occurred with previous Labour Governments’. Essentially, the Social Contract was seen by Wilson as a policy that would reduce wage inflation through good relations between the government and unions. It would mean higher public spending however. And the first two of Denis Healey’s budgets before the autumn election of October 1974 were expansionary. Healey, Chancellor of the Exchequer agreed to increase pensions, unemployment and sickness benefits, to add £550 million of subsidies on food and another £70 million for housing subsidies. Healey argued inflation caused by the expansionary budgets would be controlled by statutory price controls and voluntary wage constraint through the Social Contract. The deflation threat, Healey insisted would be averted by a combination of borrowing to finance the balance of payments deficit, and by encouraging other countries to do the same. Michael Artis and David Cobham argue this was a risky strategy, ‘it was uncertain what other countries would do, or to what extent the foreign exchange markets would finance a UK balance of payments deficit’. However, Artis and Cobham insist, although the strategy was a risky one, ‘there was in fact no viable alternative to the government’. The expansionary budgets were designed to promote the Social Contract, and secure further votes in the autumn election, which Labour did win with a majority of three seats.
Wilson was unwilling to open negotiations with the Trade Union Congress if it threatened the existence of the Social Contract, despite economic turmoil and rapidly increasing wage-inflation which reached a peak of 30 per cent in mid-1975. However, soaring wage inflation continued to rise, and forced Wilson to open talks with the unions concerning a new incomes policy. The Government was able to negotiate an agreement with the TUC for the introduction for a twelve month period of a voluntary £6 a week flat-rate pay increase for anybody earning less than £8,500 a year. For the better off, there would be no pay rise at all. The new Incomes Policy was drawn up with the help of two respected Trade Union leaders Jack Jones and Hugh Scanlon. Jones was a staunch Labour supporter, and was concerned that the government would collapse if effective action was not taken to ensure pay restraint. Taylor is adamant that the proposal for a flat-rate pay norm was very much in tune with the needs and aspirations of his lower paid members in the Transport and General Workers Union.Tomlinson argues the flat-rate increase had a significant impact, especially notable on the public sector. Healey, also introduced his first deflationary budget in April, as a means of reducing inflation. He announced increases in income tax and VAT, and made cuts in public spending.
In this period, Wilson also made changes to Labour’s ‘Industrial Policy 1973’, part of their election manifesto, by introducing a White Paper ‘The Regeneration of British Industry’. Wilson aimed to remove features of the original industrial policy which were felt to be most difficult. The original industrial policy was influenced very much by the left of the party, in particular Tony Benn, who was shadow Secretary for Industry in 1973. Benn wanted the government to play a more influential role in the running of large private companies. However, Wilson firmly supported a mixed economy, and although he shared Benn’s concern about the future of British manufacturing, was not prepared to introduce radical proposals such as Benn’s wish to nationalise the top twenty-five private firms, and the imposition of import controls against foreign manufactured goods. Mark Wickham-Jones concludes, ‘Labour’s Programme 1973 and the White Paper The Regeneration of British Industry published in August 1974 contained a very different set of proposals’. Part of Labour’s industrial policy was the creation of the National Enterprise Board which was to be a new source of investment for manufacturing firms. Benn supported the idea of this new committee, but when Wilson reshuffled his cabinet found himself demoted from Secretary of Industry to Energy. The NEB, created in 1975, resulted in total government funding for industrial innovation increasing by 39 per cent between 1974 and 1976. However, the NEB must be regarded as an overall failure. Doug Hoyle describes the NEB as ‘a toothless tabby cat’. It did nationalise the shipbuilding and aerospace industries, Rolls Royce and the engineering firm, Alfred Herbert. But these were all failing industries, Taylor refers to the as ‘lame ducks’. The NEB failed to provide the new jobs or new growth opportunities it promised.
On 5 March, 1976, Britain was hit by a sudden decline in sterling, and within a fortnight Harold Wilson had retired. James Callaghan replaced him as leader of the Labour Party and Prime Minister, and in April, he and Healey introduced a budget which made a number of changes in tax allowances and expenditures, which were conditional upon stage Two in the Pay Policy agreed with Trade Unions. The second stage of the Incomes Policy limited wage increases to 3%, and was supported by Jones and Scanlon. Healey proceeded to announce that public expenditure would be further reduced, and publicly announced monetary targets. However, the decline in sterling continued, falling from $2.04 in late 1975 to $1.65 in 1976, and the Chancellor announced Britain had applied to the International Monetary Fund for a loan. Part of the agreement with the IMF included a ‘Letter of Intent’, in which Healey promised further cuts in public spending. Allsopp declares that the sterling crisis caused a ‘major change in policy’. Prior to the sterling crisis, policy appeared to be to seek a competitive pound as an aid to the longer term health of industry and as a method of managing demand. This would lead to export-led expansion, reducing the need for deficit finance, and cutting expenditure, and, in 1976, this policy was working. The world economy was expanding, wages and prices were coming under control and industry was extremely cost competitive. The balance of payments deficit had fallen to 0.8 per cent of GDP. Tomlinson agrees, ‘down to the autumn of 1976 the fall in the exchange rate was not regarded as a problem, as it aided the balance of payments’. However, the exchange rate continued to fall, and ‘was out of hand in the summer of 1976’, causing Callaghan to seek to politically damaging aid from the IMF. However, the securing of the IMF loan, insists Artis and Cobham calmed the foreign exchanges and the financial markets and was pursued by a period of falling inflation, strengthening the balance of payments and economic recovery. By January 1977, the Chancellor was able to promise tax cuts, albeit they were conditional on a third year of continued agreement with the unions on pay restraint. Stage Three of the pay policy set maximum pay rises at 10 per cent, and unions confirmed the twelve month rule. Relations with the trade unions were good and the government was able to introduce a deflationary budget in October, and by the end of the year, the economy was in a healthy position; inflation was lower in 1977 than it had been in 1976, unemployment was falling and the balance of payments position was strengthening. ‘The favourable economic conditions of 1977’, Artis and Cobham assert, ‘continued into 1978: the annual rate of inflation fell below 10% in February for the first time since October 1973’.
Despite an improving economy, Callaghan saw the key to sustaining the recovery as being a return to a more formal pay policy. He insisted on a 5 per cent overall wage rise norm in 1978/79, which was so low that it even confounded his own supporters in trade unions. Taylor argues ‘they refused to believe he was serious in his insistence on such a low pay rise figure’. In truth, Callaghan miscalculated the situation. Pay restraint had been effectively enforced on trade unions since 1974, and rank and file workers were anxious for a return to free-bargaining wage control. The government had been fortunate that they had allies in influential trade union leaders, Jones and Scanlon, but when these two men retired in the early months of 1978, they were replaced by weak and ineffective leaders. When Ford Motor Company workers demanded a pay rise above the 5 per cent norm, and after a seven-week long dispute, they achieved a 17 per cent pay increase, Wilson’s response was an attempt to apply financial sanctions against errant private companies that defied the pay policy, but he was defeated in the House of Commons. This defeat was a metaphor for the defeat of the Social Contract, and over the following weeks and months, groups of workers from different industries demanded pay rises. The result was the ‘Winter of Discontent’, numerous strikes and industrial disputes. Manual council workers and hospital staff went on strike, and images of piling rubbish on the streets and the unburied dead were to play a major role in the Labour’s defeat at the next election.
G.C Peden is critical of the Labour government, because during its two terms in office, relative poverty increased. The cuts in public expenditure during 1976 may have reduced inflation levels, but saw unemployment rise dramatically to its highest rate since the 1930s. Unemployment increased from 595,000 in 1973, to over 1,383,000 in 1978, increasing the number of people reliant on benefit. In the same period local authority house completions fell 26 per cent from 151,800 in 1976 to 112,300 in 1978, and, education expenditure in 1978/79 was back to the level of 1973/74. According to Peden, NHS expenditure only appeared to rise because of rising costs in the industry. For members of the Labour party on the left, the cuts in public spending were a bitter disappointment, and a betrayal of socialist policy. The government seemed to move away from Keynesian doctrine, towards a monetarist approach, or towards a ‘monetarised keynesianism’. Peden argues the sterling crisis of 1976 marked the end of the Keynesian era in British economic history, emphasised by a speech delivered by James Callaghan at the Labour Party Conference in September 1976, in which he argued government could no longer ‘spend’ its ‘way out of a recession’. Tomlinson disagrees with Peden, instead he insists economic policy was already moving away from Keynesianism well before the sterling crisis and Callaghan’s speech. Tomlinson is less critical of the Labour government and its economic record. He puts its record in context, and makes comparisons with France, West Germany and Italy. He asserts Britain’s inflation record for the period as a whole is markedly better than Italy’s. And, he notes Britain’s public expenditure record fairs better than West Germany’s in 1978/79. This supports Allsopp’s view that national debt fell as a percentage of GDP between 1974-79.
Labour’s economic record can be criticised. Alternatively it can be praised. Wilson and Callaghan did surprisingly well, despite the economic crisis that existed when Labour took power in 1974. Tomlinson argues political opponents have spoken of the period ‘in absurdly exaggerated terms’. Even New Labour have suggested the 1970s were a disastrous period to emphasise the distance travelled between ‘New’ and ‘Old’. But, if we do accept that the economy was in a disastrous state by 1979, as Peden suggests, this was not simply the result of economic doctrine, but of numerous external factors, such as poor management within large private companies. Of course the government made mistakes, Artis concludes ‘all governments do’. The Social Contract, for example, was essentially a failure, Taylor quotes Edmund Dell’s description of Labour’s deal with the unions as a ‘disaster’. However, given the economic background to the Labour Party’s ascendancy to government, and with hindsight reviewing the economic crises of the 1980s, judgement of the economic doctrine of the 1974-79 Labour government as disastrous, as Margaret Thatcher claimed, is probably harsh. When Labour ended office , inflation was lower than in 1974, growth is resumed, unemployment falling and the balance of payments account stronger. Historians on the ‘right’ have generally been more critical than historian’s on the left, such as ‘Artis’ and ‘Cobham’, who genuinely believe the economic record of the 1974-79 Labour Party is good given the worldwide economic setting of the period.
Bibliography
Allsopp, Christopher, ‘Macroeconomic Policy’, in Artis and Cobham (eds), ‘Labour’s economic policies: 1974-1979’ (Manchester, 1991)
Artis, Michael, ‘Social Democracy in hard times: the economic record of the Labour government 1974-79’ in ‘Twentieth Century British History, Volume 3’. (1992)
Artis and Cobham, ‘The Background’ in Artis and Cobham (eds), ‘Labour’s economic policies: 1974-1979’ (Manchester, 1991)
Artis and Robin Bladen-Hovell, ‘A model-based analysis’, in Artis and Cobham (eds), ‘Labour’s economic policies: 1974-1979’ (Manchester, 1991)
Cronin, James E, ‘New Labour’s pasts: the Labour Party and it’s discontents’ (2004).
Peden, G.C, ‘British Economic and Social Policy: Lloyd George to Margaret Thatcher’ (Oxford, 1985)
Taylor, Robert, ‘The Rise and Fall of the Social Contract’, in Seldon and Hickson, ‘New Labour, Old Labour: The Wilson and Callaghan Governments, 1974-79’
Tomlinson, Jim, ‘Economic Policy’, in Seldon and Hickson, ‘New Labour, Old Labour: The Wilson and Callaghan Governments, 1974-79’
Westaway, Tony ‘Stabilisation and Fiscal Reform’, in Maunder, Peter (ed), ‘The British Economy in the 1970s’ (London, 1980)
Wickham-Jones, Mark, ‘Economic Strategy and the Labour Party: Politics and Policy-making, 1970-83’ (New York, 1996)
Joseph Lappin 26/04/07
Wilson’s Labour Party assumed power from Heath’s Conservatives, on 4 March 1974 on the brink of the most testing economic crisis experienced for over two decades and in circumstances of industrial turmoil and political uncertainty. Tomlinson describes labour’s economic inheritance as a ‘poisoned chalice’. The Heath Government had embarked on an expansionary fiscal and monetary policy, and initiated the Heath-Barber boom, a strategy of creating and sustaining a high level of aggregate demand in the hope of encouraging a great leap in industrial development, with favourable effects on productivity and growth. And although unemployment fell as a result of the boom, inflation increased from under 7 per cent in 1972, to a rate of over 10 per cent in late 1973. The boom also caused a sterling crisis in June 1972, the floating of the Pound and subsequent depreciation in the exchange rate. Heath and his cabinet were forced to raise interest rates to record levels and cut its public spending. Heath’s position deteriorated further, when the National Union of Miners called a strike on 12 November 1973, just as the oil crisis, which saw oil prices quadruple, hit Britain. Allsopp insists, ‘the legacy of the Heath government’s dash for growth combined with the first oil crisis meant that the starting point’ for Labour ‘was one of extraordinary difficulty’. The industrial relations crisis with the miners effectively brought Heath’s period in office to an end. The miner’s dispute, combined with a reduction in oil supply, led to a three-day working week being imposed on industry to save energy. At the same time wage inflation was rocketing, and Heath’s attempts to control it with the policy of threshold agreements failed. With the manufacturing industry in Britain in turmoil, Heath decided to call an election on the theme of ‘Who Rules?’ Heath was defeated, in an election in which neither the Conservatives nor Labour did well. The Labour Party was handed the task of forming the next government, ‘albeit without the mandate of an overall majority, for the election resulted in a hung Parliament’. Nevertheless, Labour was the largest party, and arrived in Government with inflation higher than in 1970 when the Conservatives took office, the balance of payments in the red and the exchange rate sinking quickly. The public sector deficit was at a peacetime high and Tomlinson agrees, ‘when Labour took office almost every economic indicator was moving adversely’.
Wilson’s aim when he first arrived at Downing Street, was to solve the immediate crisis with the National Union of Miners, and he swiftly ended the strike by granting the miner’s demands, thus putting an end to the three-day working week. Action was quickly begun to repeal and replace Heath’s detested Industrial relations Act. When Labour was in opposition, they promised the electorate that they could solve the problems with the unions that had marred Heath’s period in office, and indeed Wilson’s earlier period as Prime Minister between 1966-70. James Cronin, describes Labour’s agreement with the unions, the Social Contract, as a ‘deal in which the party agreed to refrain from statutory incomes policy while in office, to restore and augment Union rights, and most importantly, to use the powers of the state to increase the social wage in the hope that unions would respond by moderating wage claims, and where possible, discouraging the resort to strikes’. Robert Taylor adds, the Social Contract aimed to ‘establish a much closer relationship with the Trade Unions that would prevent any repetition of the kind of trouble that had occurred with previous Labour Governments’. Essentially, the Social Contract was seen by Wilson as a policy that would reduce wage inflation through good relations between the government and unions. It would mean higher public spending however. And the first two of Denis Healey’s budgets before the autumn election of October 1974 were expansionary. Healey, Chancellor of the Exchequer agreed to increase pensions, unemployment and sickness benefits, to add £550 million of subsidies on food and another £70 million for housing subsidies. Healey argued inflation caused by the expansionary budgets would be controlled by statutory price controls and voluntary wage constraint through the Social Contract. The deflation threat, Healey insisted would be averted by a combination of borrowing to finance the balance of payments deficit, and by encouraging other countries to do the same. Michael Artis and David Cobham argue this was a risky strategy, ‘it was uncertain what other countries would do, or to what extent the foreign exchange markets would finance a UK balance of payments deficit’. However, Artis and Cobham insist, although the strategy was a risky one, ‘there was in fact no viable alternative to the government’. The expansionary budgets were designed to promote the Social Contract, and secure further votes in the autumn election, which Labour did win with a majority of three seats.
Wilson was unwilling to open negotiations with the Trade Union Congress if it threatened the existence of the Social Contract, despite economic turmoil and rapidly increasing wage-inflation which reached a peak of 30 per cent in mid-1975. However, soaring wage inflation continued to rise, and forced Wilson to open talks with the unions concerning a new incomes policy. The Government was able to negotiate an agreement with the TUC for the introduction for a twelve month period of a voluntary £6 a week flat-rate pay increase for anybody earning less than £8,500 a year. For the better off, there would be no pay rise at all. The new Incomes Policy was drawn up with the help of two respected Trade Union leaders Jack Jones and Hugh Scanlon. Jones was a staunch Labour supporter, and was concerned that the government would collapse if effective action was not taken to ensure pay restraint. Taylor is adamant that the proposal for a flat-rate pay norm was very much in tune with the needs and aspirations of his lower paid members in the Transport and General Workers Union.Tomlinson argues the flat-rate increase had a significant impact, especially notable on the public sector. Healey, also introduced his first deflationary budget in April, as a means of reducing inflation. He announced increases in income tax and VAT, and made cuts in public spending.
In this period, Wilson also made changes to Labour’s ‘Industrial Policy 1973’, part of their election manifesto, by introducing a White Paper ‘The Regeneration of British Industry’. Wilson aimed to remove features of the original industrial policy which were felt to be most difficult. The original industrial policy was influenced very much by the left of the party, in particular Tony Benn, who was shadow Secretary for Industry in 1973. Benn wanted the government to play a more influential role in the running of large private companies. However, Wilson firmly supported a mixed economy, and although he shared Benn’s concern about the future of British manufacturing, was not prepared to introduce radical proposals such as Benn’s wish to nationalise the top twenty-five private firms, and the imposition of import controls against foreign manufactured goods. Mark Wickham-Jones concludes, ‘Labour’s Programme 1973 and the White Paper The Regeneration of British Industry published in August 1974 contained a very different set of proposals’. Part of Labour’s industrial policy was the creation of the National Enterprise Board which was to be a new source of investment for manufacturing firms. Benn supported the idea of this new committee, but when Wilson reshuffled his cabinet found himself demoted from Secretary of Industry to Energy. The NEB, created in 1975, resulted in total government funding for industrial innovation increasing by 39 per cent between 1974 and 1976. However, the NEB must be regarded as an overall failure. Doug Hoyle describes the NEB as ‘a toothless tabby cat’. It did nationalise the shipbuilding and aerospace industries, Rolls Royce and the engineering firm, Alfred Herbert. But these were all failing industries, Taylor refers to the as ‘lame ducks’. The NEB failed to provide the new jobs or new growth opportunities it promised.
On 5 March, 1976, Britain was hit by a sudden decline in sterling, and within a fortnight Harold Wilson had retired. James Callaghan replaced him as leader of the Labour Party and Prime Minister, and in April, he and Healey introduced a budget which made a number of changes in tax allowances and expenditures, which were conditional upon stage Two in the Pay Policy agreed with Trade Unions. The second stage of the Incomes Policy limited wage increases to 3%, and was supported by Jones and Scanlon. Healey proceeded to announce that public expenditure would be further reduced, and publicly announced monetary targets. However, the decline in sterling continued, falling from $2.04 in late 1975 to $1.65 in 1976, and the Chancellor announced Britain had applied to the International Monetary Fund for a loan. Part of the agreement with the IMF included a ‘Letter of Intent’, in which Healey promised further cuts in public spending. Allsopp declares that the sterling crisis caused a ‘major change in policy’. Prior to the sterling crisis, policy appeared to be to seek a competitive pound as an aid to the longer term health of industry and as a method of managing demand. This would lead to export-led expansion, reducing the need for deficit finance, and cutting expenditure, and, in 1976, this policy was working. The world economy was expanding, wages and prices were coming under control and industry was extremely cost competitive. The balance of payments deficit had fallen to 0.8 per cent of GDP. Tomlinson agrees, ‘down to the autumn of 1976 the fall in the exchange rate was not regarded as a problem, as it aided the balance of payments’. However, the exchange rate continued to fall, and ‘was out of hand in the summer of 1976’, causing Callaghan to seek to politically damaging aid from the IMF. However, the securing of the IMF loan, insists Artis and Cobham calmed the foreign exchanges and the financial markets and was pursued by a period of falling inflation, strengthening the balance of payments and economic recovery. By January 1977, the Chancellor was able to promise tax cuts, albeit they were conditional on a third year of continued agreement with the unions on pay restraint. Stage Three of the pay policy set maximum pay rises at 10 per cent, and unions confirmed the twelve month rule. Relations with the trade unions were good and the government was able to introduce a deflationary budget in October, and by the end of the year, the economy was in a healthy position; inflation was lower in 1977 than it had been in 1976, unemployment was falling and the balance of payments position was strengthening. ‘The favourable economic conditions of 1977’, Artis and Cobham assert, ‘continued into 1978: the annual rate of inflation fell below 10% in February for the first time since October 1973’.
Despite an improving economy, Callaghan saw the key to sustaining the recovery as being a return to a more formal pay policy. He insisted on a 5 per cent overall wage rise norm in 1978/79, which was so low that it even confounded his own supporters in trade unions. Taylor argues ‘they refused to believe he was serious in his insistence on such a low pay rise figure’. In truth, Callaghan miscalculated the situation. Pay restraint had been effectively enforced on trade unions since 1974, and rank and file workers were anxious for a return to free-bargaining wage control. The government had been fortunate that they had allies in influential trade union leaders, Jones and Scanlon, but when these two men retired in the early months of 1978, they were replaced by weak and ineffective leaders. When Ford Motor Company workers demanded a pay rise above the 5 per cent norm, and after a seven-week long dispute, they achieved a 17 per cent pay increase, Wilson’s response was an attempt to apply financial sanctions against errant private companies that defied the pay policy, but he was defeated in the House of Commons. This defeat was a metaphor for the defeat of the Social Contract, and over the following weeks and months, groups of workers from different industries demanded pay rises. The result was the ‘Winter of Discontent’, numerous strikes and industrial disputes. Manual council workers and hospital staff went on strike, and images of piling rubbish on the streets and the unburied dead were to play a major role in the Labour’s defeat at the next election.
G.C Peden is critical of the Labour government, because during its two terms in office, relative poverty increased. The cuts in public expenditure during 1976 may have reduced inflation levels, but saw unemployment rise dramatically to its highest rate since the 1930s. Unemployment increased from 595,000 in 1973, to over 1,383,000 in 1978, increasing the number of people reliant on benefit. In the same period local authority house completions fell 26 per cent from 151,800 in 1976 to 112,300 in 1978, and, education expenditure in 1978/79 was back to the level of 1973/74. According to Peden, NHS expenditure only appeared to rise because of rising costs in the industry. For members of the Labour party on the left, the cuts in public spending were a bitter disappointment, and a betrayal of socialist policy. The government seemed to move away from Keynesian doctrine, towards a monetarist approach, or towards a ‘monetarised keynesianism’. Peden argues the sterling crisis of 1976 marked the end of the Keynesian era in British economic history, emphasised by a speech delivered by James Callaghan at the Labour Party Conference in September 1976, in which he argued government could no longer ‘spend’ its ‘way out of a recession’. Tomlinson disagrees with Peden, instead he insists economic policy was already moving away from Keynesianism well before the sterling crisis and Callaghan’s speech. Tomlinson is less critical of the Labour government and its economic record. He puts its record in context, and makes comparisons with France, West Germany and Italy. He asserts Britain’s inflation record for the period as a whole is markedly better than Italy’s. And, he notes Britain’s public expenditure record fairs better than West Germany’s in 1978/79. This supports Allsopp’s view that national debt fell as a percentage of GDP between 1974-79.
Labour’s economic record can be criticised. Alternatively it can be praised. Wilson and Callaghan did surprisingly well, despite the economic crisis that existed when Labour took power in 1974. Tomlinson argues political opponents have spoken of the period ‘in absurdly exaggerated terms’. Even New Labour have suggested the 1970s were a disastrous period to emphasise the distance travelled between ‘New’ and ‘Old’. But, if we do accept that the economy was in a disastrous state by 1979, as Peden suggests, this was not simply the result of economic doctrine, but of numerous external factors, such as poor management within large private companies. Of course the government made mistakes, Artis concludes ‘all governments do’. The Social Contract, for example, was essentially a failure, Taylor quotes Edmund Dell’s description of Labour’s deal with the unions as a ‘disaster’. However, given the economic background to the Labour Party’s ascendancy to government, and with hindsight reviewing the economic crises of the 1980s, judgement of the economic doctrine of the 1974-79 Labour government as disastrous, as Margaret Thatcher claimed, is probably harsh. When Labour ended office , inflation was lower than in 1974, growth is resumed, unemployment falling and the balance of payments account stronger. Historians on the ‘right’ have generally been more critical than historian’s on the left, such as ‘Artis’ and ‘Cobham’, who genuinely believe the economic record of the 1974-79 Labour Party is good given the worldwide economic setting of the period.
Bibliography
Allsopp, Christopher, ‘Macroeconomic Policy’, in Artis and Cobham (eds), ‘Labour’s economic policies: 1974-1979’ (Manchester, 1991)
Artis, Michael, ‘Social Democracy in hard times: the economic record of the Labour government 1974-79’ in ‘Twentieth Century British History, Volume 3’. (1992)
Artis and Cobham, ‘The Background’ in Artis and Cobham (eds), ‘Labour’s economic policies: 1974-1979’ (Manchester, 1991)
Artis and Robin Bladen-Hovell, ‘A model-based analysis’, in Artis and Cobham (eds), ‘Labour’s economic policies: 1974-1979’ (Manchester, 1991)
Cronin, James E, ‘New Labour’s pasts: the Labour Party and it’s discontents’ (2004).
Peden, G.C, ‘British Economic and Social Policy: Lloyd George to Margaret Thatcher’ (Oxford, 1985)
Taylor, Robert, ‘The Rise and Fall of the Social Contract’, in Seldon and Hickson, ‘New Labour, Old Labour: The Wilson and Callaghan Governments, 1974-79’
Tomlinson, Jim, ‘Economic Policy’, in Seldon and Hickson, ‘New Labour, Old Labour: The Wilson and Callaghan Governments, 1974-79’
Westaway, Tony ‘Stabilisation and Fiscal Reform’, in Maunder, Peter (ed), ‘The British Economy in the 1970s’ (London, 1980)
Wickham-Jones, Mark, ‘Economic Strategy and the Labour Party: Politics and Policy-making, 1970-83’ (New York, 1996)
Joseph Lappin 26/04/07
21/04/2007
The United States of Arsenal?

Arsene Wenger looked worried at his weekly press conference yesterday. The usual swagger that normally accompanies Arsenal’s most successful manager since Herbert Chapman deserted the Frenchman as he entered the Arsenal Press office. Just hours earlier, Stan Kroenke, the American businessman who owns three sports teams in the US across three sporting codes, quietly increased his shareholdings in the London club to 12 per cent. Kroenke Sports Enterprises previously held over 10 per cent after buying up ITV’s shares in the club last month.
Kroenke’s arrival at the Emirates Stadium has had a devastating effect upon the Arsenal board. On Thursday David Dein, the Arsenal Vice Chairman since 1988, who was instrumental in bringing Arsene Wenger to the club was effectively sacked after ‘irreconcilable differences’ between him and other board members made his position untenable. Peter Hill wood, the Arsenal Chairman, has refused to explain the specific reasons for Dein’s sudden departure, but there is no doubt that his abrupt dismissal is linked to Kroenke’s rising strength within the boardroom. It is no secret that Dein would like to see Kroenke play a ‘bigger role’ in the club. In other words, he supports an American takeover. But this put him at odds with the Arsenal chairman and the other major shareholders at the club who want to hold onto their shares. Hill-Wood dismayed ‘I would be horrified to see ownership of the club go across the Atlantic’. But this is just what has happened recently in Manchester and Liverpool. Neither Manchester United nor Liverpool fans were happy to see their club fall into the hands of American ownership, but it is rare to hear members from either set of fans complain about the finanical advantages that these wealthy tycoons bring with them. Millions of pounds have been and will be spared for new players The finanical advantages brought to one of Arsenal's rivals, Chelsea, by their Russian owner Roman Abramovich are obvious, and a source of jealousy for Gooners.
Dein, it seems, is worried about Arsenal’s long term competitiveness. Although the new Emirates stadium generates around one million pounds extra per match than the old, much smaller Highbury did, the large sclae constructction of the giant glossy stadium has left Arsenal Football Club in hundreds of millions of debt. There is no doubt that Arsenal will not be able to compete with the rest of the ‘big four’ come this summer in the transfer market. Dein knows an American takeover would result in huge investment in the club, and allow Arsene Wenger to complement his exciting, but young squad, with ‘big’ names to compete for the Premiership title.
Kroenke’s arrival at the Emirates Stadium has had a devastating effect upon the Arsenal board. On Thursday David Dein, the Arsenal Vice Chairman since 1988, who was instrumental in bringing Arsene Wenger to the club was effectively sacked after ‘irreconcilable differences’ between him and other board members made his position untenable. Peter Hill wood, the Arsenal Chairman, has refused to explain the specific reasons for Dein’s sudden departure, but there is no doubt that his abrupt dismissal is linked to Kroenke’s rising strength within the boardroom. It is no secret that Dein would like to see Kroenke play a ‘bigger role’ in the club. In other words, he supports an American takeover. But this put him at odds with the Arsenal chairman and the other major shareholders at the club who want to hold onto their shares. Hill-Wood dismayed ‘I would be horrified to see ownership of the club go across the Atlantic’. But this is just what has happened recently in Manchester and Liverpool. Neither Manchester United nor Liverpool fans were happy to see their club fall into the hands of American ownership, but it is rare to hear members from either set of fans complain about the finanical advantages that these wealthy tycoons bring with them. Millions of pounds have been and will be spared for new players The finanical advantages brought to one of Arsenal's rivals, Chelsea, by their Russian owner Roman Abramovich are obvious, and a source of jealousy for Gooners.
Dein, it seems, is worried about Arsenal’s long term competitiveness. Although the new Emirates stadium generates around one million pounds extra per match than the old, much smaller Highbury did, the large sclae constructction of the giant glossy stadium has left Arsenal Football Club in hundreds of millions of debt. There is no doubt that Arsenal will not be able to compete with the rest of the ‘big four’ come this summer in the transfer market. Dein knows an American takeover would result in huge investment in the club, and allow Arsene Wenger to complement his exciting, but young squad, with ‘big’ names to compete for the Premiership title.
Fans are worried too. The two American businessmen who recently acquired the purchase of Liverpool, with whom Arsenal are vying with for third place, have promised to flaunt their wealth by spending extravagantly in the close season on new players. Some fans are questioning the board’s reasoning. If Arsenal are currently fourth in the league, way behind the top two in terms of points, how will they perform next year if the financial gap between them and the top is clubs is going to increase.
Since Dein became Vice chairman in 1988, he has done more than most at Arsenal in transforming the London club into one of world football’s most successful and most supported clubs. Wenger often speaks of Dein’s endeavours in helping create an exciting squad that consists of some of Europe’s most sought after youthful talent. Both Dein and Wenger accept however, that in order to compete with England’s and Europe’s top sides more investment is needed to bolster Arsenal’s young squad. This can only come in the form of Kroenke’s amassed millions and his profitable Sports Enterprises company.
If Arsenal fans want Dein to return to the club, I suspect they will not be disappointed. It is likely the ex-Chairman will launch a joint bid with his ally Kroenke in the near future. If successful, Dein would most probably assume the role of chairman and continue to build on the accomplishments he has already achieved at the club he clearly adores. As an Arsenal fan myself, let’s hope we haven’t heard the last of this saga yet.
Joseph Lappin
21/04/07
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
